Lex, shame, shame, shame on me! You have posted such beautiful chapters and I got to reading and reviewing them only now. Well, but at last, here I go.
Chapter 23I really love the way you write; how skillfully you can balance the amount of tension and action in this chapter. And as I’ve already said earlier, your writing gets better and better with every new chapter.
I really like the picture of Harry and Severus dueling, or rather how they are so eager to beat one another and just can’t wait for the one to give another the slightest pretext for a hex. Actually, this very chapter reminds of "Occlumency" chapter in OotF. When at the beginning of it, Severus and Sirius face each, their wands drawn ready to strike. But in the book it is Harry who finally flings himself in between them to prevent them for any fights. I really love the image you've created.
But what really makes this chapter for me is
Hermione and her actions. You make her so brave and selfless. Though both Harry and Severus are capable of altruistic deeds, when it comes to dealing with one another, they forget everything else, see red and their only motivation for actions is to hurt the other. I like that Hermione, despite being terribly distressed and saddened, is still able to act in such a cool and matter-of-fact way. And what I simply adore about her is the way you describe Severus sees her.
QUOTE
even when she wasn’t moving, she was very beautiful – no longer a girl, but a mature young adult. He wondered if she knew how much she had transformed in his presence.
or
QUOTE
He felt his anger gently ebb away as he watched her soft lips wrap around the words she was speaking.
And poor poor Severus, again.
QUOTE
the one that never fit into someone else enough not to tear their lives apart.
PS: Reading through other people’s feedback on that chapter, I can see that majority of what I’ve written here, including the quotes, has already been mentioned by the others. Sorry, for the repetition, I just wanted you to know what I think about the chapter. And it also proves how good your writing has become!
Chapter 24Oh
Lex, what are you doing to your readers? You should have warned us about the dangers in this particular chapter. I didn't mind the new information in it, and I certainly don't think there was too much stuff. But I definitely was not ready for the Godric’s Hollow episode. I am positively convinced that this part is
your best descriptive piece of writing yet. It was so highly elaborate with many details, beautiful, sensitive and intensive. Maybe it's just the autumn mood I am in at the moment, but while reading this part I felt the well-too-known burning sensation behind my eyes. It was so well-written and so moving! For the hundredth time,
well-done! And the suspense with which you introduce the memory - three whole paragraphs! Really, my favorite part from your whole story yet.
It's completely impossible to pick the best quote from the memory passage, as I would have to quote the whole of it, but I think the following are really great,
QUOTE
No one noticed or cared that there was a man entering the invisible lot, for he blended into nothingness against the dark that was beginning to suffocate him.
and
QUOTE
Gently pushing aside the blankets and wood, a baby came into view.
On the other hand, and now I hope you don't mind, there are parts in the chapter which I don't like much. One of them simply doesn’t suit with the mature Hermione any more. I’m talking about the hug Hermione gives McGonagall. You have pointed out many times that Hermione has matured with Severus immensely, and I definitely agree with you, so I think it would be more appropriate for her to appreciate McGonagall's apology in a more subtle way. You know, it's just a suggestion.

But then, I am
so happy McGonagall understands them and admits to her mistake.
The second part which I see just a little over the top is Hermione saying/thinking to Severus how much she loves him. I am perfectly aware that your story is also a romance and such lines are simply inevitable.

I just think there might have been another way of putting it. I'm sorry, I really
do hope that you don't mind me saying it.
Actually, at one moment it seemed to me that in the paragraph both their voices are being heard, which of course, would change my opinion of this part considerably. That Hermione starts it
QUOTE
…No, I’m not smiling because I think that was foolish or stupid, I am so happy that you are willing to trust me with such things. I will always be there for you.
and Severus finishes it,
QUOTE
Thank you for understanding, thank you for watching that with me, thank you for helping me when I’m too proud to admit I need and want it. I love you, I love you….
But this, I suppose, is only my reading something which in reality is not in the text, right? But being it the way I read it, it would be a perfect way of showing how Severus and Hermione are connected, with their ideas being voiced one after another without any breaks in between. Sorry again, just a suggestion.
But on the whole, this is a very good chapter (yet again) and the Godric’s Hollow episode makes up for any minute flaws in it.
Chapter 25I really like the opening paragraphs of this chapter. They are so intense, and honestly, I trembled with expectation reading them. It is a funeral service, so everyone and everything is so calm, serene and tranquil, but then there is this undercurrent of tension and anticipation. Two such different things and yet you manage to combine them so well and create the atmosphere of the scene.
For me, the whole scene is represented by this image,
QUOTE
The silence continued for several minutes that seemed like hours, every ear straining to hear a betrayal of a presence, every hand tightening the grip on a wand.
And then the
actions! You really make your readers see and feel the turmoil of the fights, with all the spells being cast in every possible direction and the sounds resounding everywhere.
I like that you play with the idea of
love. That not only the intimate love between Severus and Hermione is powerful, but also other kinds of love, such as the deep friendship between Harry and Hermione, are capable of the magic. I would say the whole love concept is very original idea.
As for this part,
QUOTE
As of right now, her option was the best he could think of, besides the fact that he would have to use the power of love alongside Harry Potter. That, Severus decided, was a sacrifice he would have to make, but it was a huge one.
I know that Severus sees his help as a sacrifice from his side, but then on the other hand, he can still look once again into Harry's eyes. They might remind him of the love of his life and then it wouldn't be such a sacrifice any more, because it would be as if he was performing the magic along and for Lily and not with Harry. I'm really keeping my fingers crossed for this solution, as you've mentioned earlier that Severus hasn't looked into Harry's eyes for a long time, so maybe not it is time. I know, I will have to wait and see, right?

And just by the way, I envy you your discipline with the "one post per week" thing - I will have to work on this scheme a bit myself as my posting habits are simply inexcusable.

Keep writing and posting as your story is simply great!
And…ehm…sorry, for the length, but as double posts are not allowed I had to squeeze the three chapters into one post. Sorry, once again.

~Jana