Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Dumbledore A Deatheater In The Movie!?
Veritaserum Forums > General > Archived Threads > Movies Archive
Tash
Everyone in the movie, when Cornelius Fudge and Albus Dumbledore are speaking together in the Court Hearing, dumbledore says: "The Dark Lord's return is incontrevertible(or something like that) LOL!! He just said Dark Lord, remember Harry Potter saying anyone who says Dark Lord is a death eater. Holy cow, what a big screw up the movie made sad.gif
If you guys want to see it, it can be found on the youtube link
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLud6yM47u8
Voyager
Hey that never occurred to me. Nice find that little slip up.


Mod Edit: Please remember one-liners and short posts are not permitted in this section.
Tash
Yeah, i think they rushed the movie a bit too much sad.gif


Mod Edit: Please remember one-liners and short posts are not permitted in this section.
Albus Dumbledore
Dumbledore has called Voldemort "The Dark Lord" in the books before, I am sure. It says nothing to prove that Dumbledore is a Death Eater at all. The movie was not rushed... it was just good sounding... "The Evidence that the Dark Lord has returned is incontravertible" sounds much better than "The Evidence that Voldemort has returned is incontravertible"

I am going look for instances in the book where Dumbledore says "Dark Lord".

~Albus
Tash
Yes, but fairly that is strange. Let me know when you find any! biggrin.gif


Mod Edit: Please remember one-liners and short posts are not permitted in this section.
El Barto
I agree with Tom. Not only does Dumbledore say "the Dark Lord" in the books, but if you go through you'll find Snape and Lupin...among others...that say that same phrase. Its not a mess up. That is also assuming Snape isn't a Death Eater. Trelawney also says it in the prophecy...even without being able to control herself, she still said it. There are good characters who have said "the dark lord".
talli_babe
wow i never throt about that hey thats abit fishy but dd couldnt be a death eater though he has helped harry so much and saved his life and everything snape says it too the dark lord but we all know he is a death eater so yano but hmm i wonder why they did that maybe it was a mistake aww well.
loony_lovegood1
thats really sad, the diresctor should read the books better, before making the script. dry.gif
tonks-13
lol, I never noticed that! +resovles to watch more closely+ lol OH NO Dumbledores really a secret DE! +faints+
Do the directors actually read the books before making the script? There have been alot of slip-ups in bits of the movies like that sorta thing. Makes you think though. wub.gif
x--LilMissObsessed
Lol! What a slip up. Though one good story line if he turned out to be a deatheater. Although I'm sure it doesn't make much difference. Like some of you have said, other good people have said 'The Dark Lord' before as well.
RebelRoosGirl
QUOTE(El Barto @ Jul 15 2007, 01:05 AM) [snapback]412338[/snapback]

I agree with Tom. Not only does Dumbledore say "the Dark Lord" in the books, but if you go through you'll find Snape and Lupin...among others...that say that same phrase. Its not a mess up. That is also assuming Snape isn't a Death Eater. Trelawney also says it in the prophecy...even without being able to control herself, she still said it. There are good characters who have said "the dark lord".


Exactly. I think that the term "Dark Lord" is just another way to say Voldythingy. I mean come on, sure Harry said that calling him the Dark Lord was like being in allegiance for him (not sure i remember that actually), but he was a child when he said that! and in all defense, children say a lot of things that they believe is true, without really thinking it through.
Witherwings
Ooh, I never noticed that. I guess they did rush it a little, but still... I think 'good' people called him the Dark Lord quite a few times (I mean- in the books too!) huh.gif Confusing. Well, it's interesting! sleep.gif
kid
Well Dumbledore doesnt have fear for Voldermort so it really doesnt matter what he calls him whenever he wants to. Its just that calling him the Dark Lord sounded better.

And about the movie being rushed. I would partially agree with that coz many good things were cut out from the movie, they just wanted to keep the "important" parts in. not even getting dobby when he plays such an important role in the forthcoming series.

Lord of the Rings was not cut short from its book and it was loved by all the same.
lancelot243
Not only Death Eaters are allowed to say the "Dark Lord", many good characters say it. ONe instance I can remember is Ginny's Weasley's singing Valentine to Harry in COS... the dwarf sings "The hero who conquered the dark lord"

SO it is not exclusive to DE's
Nymphadora Lupin
Now this is a pointless discussion - if you've even read the books, you'll know that loads of people say 'the Dark Lord' - and like everyone else is saying, it isn't a slip up.

I can understand if someone hasn't read the books and they think DD is a death eater, not for the reason he says Dark Lord, but because he's just so sharp and rough sometimes, but in response to the Dark Lord thing, I think it's pretty self-explanatory.

~Amy <3
MoonLight
QUOTE(Amy-- @ Jan 13 2008, 12:22 PM) [snapback]477067[/snapback]

Now this is a pointless discussion - if you've even read the books, you'll know that loads of people say 'the Dark Lord' - and like everyone else is saying, it isn't a slip up.



That's true. Didn't someone of the trio said that once too?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.