Here we go, my first DH movie post!

So, which snogging scenes should be put in or left out? Your opinions count BIG TIME! The snoggings that I remember are: Ron/Hermione, Harry/Ginny, and Ted/Victoire (depends on the epilogue). They need to keep at least the first two, because I think it foreshadows their future "19 years later" part. OK, maybe not Ted/Victoire, although it does give us a chance to see Lupin/Tonk's and Bill/Fleur's kids grown up. They MUST keep the Ron/Hermione snogging scene, because we waited for seven books for this scene. It's VERY integral. The Harry/Ginny scene again foreshadows the "19 years later". So, all in all, keep Ron/Hermione and Harry/Ginny, and leave out Ted/Victoire.

Let me know what you think! Also, tell me the snogging scenes that you, my fellow Harry Potter fans, want in this movie.

deffo leave out harry/ginny, because i'll get jealous

Mod Edit: One liners and Short posts are not allowed on the forums. Please check the rules. Thanks.

I think all three should be kept in:

Ginny and Harry one because i think it would be a very special scene and their reactions from Hermione and Ron when they both stumble in
Hermione and Ron as said above we have waited for this for quite some time so it needs to be kept in.
Ted and Victiore i personally think it should be kept in only reason being that it would be intersting to see what he looks like (Ted) in 19 years

Well I definatly want to see Ron and Hermione
Harry and Ginny.. err well Im not to fond of that but I'm pretty sure they will leave that in.
Ted/Victoire.. I think that the whole 19 years later chapter will be really short, so I'm not exaclty sure they will include that, I really wouldn't mind if they left it out, they coudl just mention it, like it was mentioned in the book.
But who could forget the Riddle!Harry and Riddle!Hermione kiss when Ron is destroying the locket? Ooooh that would be interesting to see, Dan and Emma going at it in ghost form!
But I'm sure they will leave that out.. shame lol.
So I think we will get to see the R/Hr and H/G kiss!

That is like the kiss i want to see Even though it's an evil one i don't care.It's still a kiss between H/Hr!! Dominique i disagree i think it will be left in as it is part of destroying a horcrux and that scene is about Ron and his insecurities.

Ron/Hermione i can accept as it is kind of cute but as long as the director doesn't drag it out like the Harry/Cho kiss in OOTP.

Harry/Ginny-none of the kisses as i don't think they are integral to the plot as Ginny doesn't have a major role in this book.

They really should keep the Harry/Ginny, Ron/Hermione bit in!! But I really would like to see the Harry/hermione kiss too...
Think about it... Emma Watson will probably kiss both Rupert Grint and Dan Radcliffe!!!!

Interesting. I think they should keep them all in, because I makes everything true to the book. AND, it'll be exciting to see Ron and Hermy together. I hope they show the Epilogue because I want to see the little Granger/Weasleys. Hugo and Rose, they sound cool.

I think that Harry/Ginny and Ron/Hermione kissing should be in it. I don't think that Ted/Victorie's kissing scene should be in it, because they are both ONLY going to be in the epilogue. This is what I think.

The Harry/Ginny and Ron/Hermione should be kept in. They add a lot to the movie, but the Ted/Victorie can be dropped. Besides wasn't that kiss implied? Was it "shown" in the epilogue? I can't remember. Either way, I don't believe it would affect the movie if it was dropped.

Harry/Ginny and Ron/Hermione are most likely going to be in it which they deserve to be. The scene when Ron is destroying the locket and her sees Hermione kiss harry I dont think needs to be in the movie and Ted/Victorie isnt really needed but, I would like to see that scene.

Um ... I think they should for sure put in the Ron/Hermione kiss. Maybe the Harry/Ginny kiss. Though ... you have to admit, it is pretty random so I don't know if it'll make the movie. As for when Harry and Hermione kiss for the locket scene, I think it would be good to add that in because we need to feel that the horcrux is really trying to destroy Ron - and that would destroy Ron. I don't think they'll put in the Ted/Victoire bit, though. Haha.

This'll be interesting ... they have to put in the R/Hr kiss in. They just have to. I don't think they'll cut it, as like you said, it forshaows 19 years later, and we've been waiting ... how long? I've been waiting for some R/Hr since i read GoF (back when i was still at primary-those were the days!).



I'm not sure they'd leave it out. It's important to see the evil of the locket, and some forshadowing of Ron's fears. It's be interesting to see-geez, Emma's getting it on with the boys, isn't she? I kid, i kid.

H/G i think will and should be there. It forshaowds and again, it's Harry's ability to love that's kept him alive basically.

Teddy/Victore? Why not? I can see the epilogue forming in my head as we speak ...

I think that the most important snogging scenes will be put down as Ron and Hermione (well DUH!!!!!) and the Harry and Ginny one. I just think they're so cute together, and of course, they wouldn't leave out Ron and Hermione's BIG moment, because if the director DID leave it out, I would hunt them down and slug him/her in the face!
I also think it would be quite interesting (and vaguely disturbing) to see the Riddle-Harry and Riddle-Hermione lip-lock, but I just can't see Emma going at it with both Dan AND Rupert! Rupert, definitely, but ABSOLUTELY NOT Dan!!!
As for Teddy and Victoire, I'm not sure.

Except the only thing about putting all the kisses in is that they will all get compared to one another. For example like.. Dan and Emma have more chemistry than Bonnie and Dan but the Ron and Hermione kiss was cuter.. You know what I mean? I don't think thats the point of the kisses.
But it would be pretty interesting to see the locket scene, and Ron's expression. I kind of hope that they keep it in!

Harry Potter is all about love being stronger than evil, isn't it? So I really cant' figure out how they could possibly skip the snogging scenes. Oh, and by the way, they are still teenagers, aren't they, and teenagers just do it all the time (if it's not yet your case, just wait and see :-)

yeah ... That's the scene I think that should be in the film it makes the horcrux creepier
And I like to watch H/G and R/H scene .... specially the R/H one ... I hope They both Emma And Rupert act professional in that scene ...

I AGREE ONE HUNDRED PERCENT!! That would first be reepy! Second - interesting Third - just plain...wow (i could imagine my friends jaw droping at that)

I can see the Harry/Ginny birthday kiss and then the Ron/Hermione kiss we ahve all beeen long awaiting!!!

<3333

Due to the overwhelming number of Riddle Harry/Riddle Hermione references, I have made a new list of snogging scenes.

Here it be:

Ron/Hermione
Harry/Ginny
Ted/Victoire
Riddle Harry/Riddle Hermione

Thanks for the reminders!

I'm sure they'll keep the RHr kiss because WE'VE WAITED FOR SO LONG! -sigh- and it finally happenned... the Riddle/Hermione-Riddle/Harry kiss should be interesting because it shows Ron's insecurities... poor Ron! And they should make Rupert stab the locket as soon as Dan and Emma kiss, so it isn't too long...oh, I wish I could be Emma Watson...kiss Daniel Radcliffe AND Rupert Grint? I hate her!

No, I really like her...she's just so lucky...

I don't think any of the snogging scenes should be cut in this movie because unlike in HBP there are only a few snogging scenes in the book and I believe all are quite important.

The Ginny/Harry snog showed how much they loved each other and they just couldn't keep away from each other despite what they had agreed.

The riddle Harry/ riddle Hermione one was important especially how Ron reacted to it because it pointed out his feelings for Hermione ( as if we hadn't already noticed.) I don't know how Emma would react to having to kiss both Dan and Rupert in the same film, but if it was me I know I wouldn't be complaining!

And of course - they could never leave out the Ron/Hermione kiss. It's too important, and come on, we've been waiting seven books, and by that time seven films, for it to happen. There is no way they could leave it out!

As for the Teddy/Victoire one, I'm not too sure. They might put it in to show us that the next generation are growing up too, and that they are just like Harry's, but I'm not sure that one is as important as the rest.

I think that only 3 should be kept in. The Ginny/Harry one, like you say, shows that despite Harry trying to move on, he can't because he still loves Ginny. The Ron and Hermione one...well if they cut that I think there'd be a major stampede on the directors office and WB would be in serious hot water with the fans.

The Harry/Riddle/Hermione......I guess it might be needed to make the point.

Edit; Changed my mind...they should keep all the snogging in it!! It's the last film so they may as well, a good bit of snogging never did any harm!!

Riddle!Harry and Riddle!Hermione should definitely kiss in the movie. It shows just how much Ron loves her.... how much he fears loosing her. Plus it's a little tidbit for the H/Hr fans and if they don't get it I'm pretty sure they'll kill WB. (Personally, I think it's JKR's way of saying 'get off my back! I already told you to re-read! Here it is, now stop mailing me!')
I just don't see why they shouldn't put it in, though they'll probably leave it out.

And Ginny suddenly kissing Harry HAS to be put in... there wasn't enough Ginny in the book (I'm not super mad, but she was lacking a bit) as it is, and Harry needs something to remember her by!

Okay, I'm pretty sure I've got about a billion people behind me when I say that the kiss between Ron and Hermione is required to be in the movie. It just is. More than any of the others! Period.

Oooh! Good point, HP#1_wee_lil'! How WOULD Emma feel? Very odd... Dan said that there was one year (I think he said when they were 13 and 14? I can look it up later, if I must) where they all 'fancied the hell out of each other' but then got over it...so maybe this'll bring back some feelings?

Teddy/Victoire? Hm... They didn't exactly show it in the book, did they? Nothing like the other scenes in the book- not even saying 'they were glued to each other' or anything- just little James running up to them and saying it. So I don't think they'll show it. Actually, I doubt the movie will have that final chapter at all. I know, it sucks...but I'm thinking like them. Though I will still vote/hope for them showing it- because I NEED some more freakin' Lupin.

Ya they should NOT cut the G/H scene or the R/Hr scene because the movie is probly going to be pretty dark and they should make it have a little "light" in it. As for the Riddle/harry Riddle/hermione scene I think they should animate that like they did for all the ghosts.

I just have one thing to say.

If the R/Hr kiss is cut out of the seventh movie, the director will one day mysteriously disappear, never to be found again... JUST KIDDING! But I do think that, the H/G kiss, and the Riddle Harry and Riddle Hermionie kisses are integral to the plot... but if i had to pick one it'd have to be the Ron/Hermionie... we've waited too long for it not to happen!!!

they should leave in all of them should be in the movie but i agree with No.1_HarryPotterFan, i think that we've waited long enough for that kiss between H/R. i think that that is like a NECESSITY in the movie. not H/G.

I definitely think that Harry/Ginny kiss should be there because it shows that they lvoe each other whatever happens. I also think the Ron/Hermy kiss should be there just becuase people have been waiting for it for so long.

I agree that i have also waited for a kiss from Dan and Emma.

they def need to keep harry/ginny and ron/hermione

I agree.
The Ron/Hermione kiss EVERYONE'S been waiting for.
and'll be very interesting to see Riddle Harry/Riddle Hermione kiss. (:

They should keep the Teddy/Victoire because it shows that even though Teddy lost both his parents like Harry did, he doesn't live life all depressed and stuff. It shows he's living life.

OK...
i think that the Ron/hermione kissing scene should be there because if not the producer and the director will be hunted down by hoards of angry fans that i will lead. we will trample them into crushed ants, then continue onto WB studious, squish it like the ant pile it is, and then raise enought money to pay emma and rupert to actually see the kiss. as u can see, i'm an avid R/Hr fan, and if there is no kiss i'm going to buy two HPDH dvd's so that i can burn one and crush the other.

the harry/ginny kiss should definitely be in the movie, if not i'll make a point to have a word w/ a few of the people (though on this occasion i probably won't lead a hoard of angry fans)

riddle harry/riddle hermione-u know, i just desperately need to see that for the sole purpous of laughing b/c emma was already nervous about just kissing rupert. also, i really wanna see ron's reaction!! i really hope they bring a different, more emotional side of ron that we never really got to see in the other movies. his crying has been, like, comical, not serious. but the MALFOY MANOR and the HORCRUX part are way to emotional to throw it aside comically. this is another instance in which i will hunt down producers of the movie and slug them, as well as burning down WB studios : )

I dont kno if we r really gonna see them kiss, it's probably gonna be like a ghostish thingy. but i hope so.

i'm gonna try to speep up world time right now so that we can get to 2010 quickly to finally see THE KISS and the rest of the movie!


[color=#3333FF][b]ALL HAIL PAGE 625 OF THE AMERICAN VERSION OF HARRY POTTER AND THE DEATHLY HALLOWS. YAY!!

I take it page 625 is the kiss?

Well, I really hope they leave in the H/G kiss... it's important, like you've said. I think the directors need to talk to the fans to know what to leave out.

well the snogging is basically the whole plot for a while so i think that if they dont want a really short movie then theyl need to keep quite a bit....and obviously they cant leave our ginny an harrys first aww....anywho so yeah the lavender/ron stuff does drag on a bit though...

I don't think the Harry-Ginny kiss is necessary. It's kind of a random scene, and its only purpose is to show that Harry and Ginny are back together, but actually, doesn't Harry say to Ron afterwards that it 'won't happen again'? So it doesn't really serve any purpose except to show that Harry is weak in keeping his promise to himself - to distance himself from Ginny in order to keep her safe. I guess it all depends on what the directors do with the end of the 6th film. If they never show Harry's resolution to protect Ginny, then the kiss should be in the 7th, because it shows they're together. If they do show Harry's decision to keep Ginny safe, then they shouldn't show the kiss, because it just complicates the boundaries of the Harry-Ginny relationship (though personally, I do want to see it).

The Ron-Hermione kiss is going to be in the film. I guarantee it. Why would the directors show the Ron-Hermione moments in the previous films (i.e. the awkward hug-turned-handshake in CoS, the Yule B(rawl), hand-on-hand action during the hippogriff scene in PoA) if they didn't plan on going anywhere with it? (Haha, gotta love rhetorical questions!). The kiss would be a resolution to the little hints they've placed in the other films. Obviously the directors were pretty confident that there would be a Ron-Hermione kiss and planned on showing it, or they wouldn't have bothered with the lead-up.

And the RiddleHarry-RiddleHermione kiss. My, my. I really want this scene in the movie. Really bad. I think it's a possibility that they won't have the actual kiss, but that the ghosts will just talk to Ron, tormenting him verbally. They can't leave out the Horcrux-destroying scene altogether, and the whole point of the Horcrux is that it's last resort is to cruelly torture its destroyer. So logically, they have to have the Horcrux torturing Ron; it's just a question of how they show the torture. I am really looking forward to seeing Ron's reaction. In my opinion, the more emotional the better. Let's see if they can get Rupert to show another side of his professional repetoire...

I hope (and think) that they'll leave out the Teddy/Victoire kiss. It isn't even directly shown in the books. And selfishly, I hope they leave out the entire epilogue. For me, when an author makes familiar characters age rapidly in a few paragraphs, the characters seem to lose their familiarity and become new characters. When I was reading the epilogue, I didn't feel like I knew epilogue-Harry and epilogue-Ron etc. They seemed foreign to me.

Edit: I hope they go easy on the Ron-Lavender action in the 6th. Ew. The less of that the better.

I think they will have Harry/Ginny Kiss cause it's the only one, and it sets up anger from Ron. They will of course have to Ron/Hermione Kiss, but I think that's about all which doesn't bother me...They better not make a big fuss about it like the Harry/Cho kiss, that was a nightmare!

I think they need the Harry/Ginny kiss because it shows that they still want to be together whatever happens. I am looking forward to seeing Ron/hermione's first kiss and i also think that they need the riddle-harry/riddle-hermione one to show that ron is freaked out by hermione and ahrry ever getting together.

REAL Harry and REAL Hermione didn't kiss. Riddle-Harry and Riddle-Hermione kissed. But REAL Hermione kissed Ron.

I would love to see this kiss! I noticed in the 5th film, Harry was not holding Cho while they kissed. I think the Director did that on purpose. In movie 6 I have a feeling that Harry is going to be holding Ginny close while they kiss I cannot wait for movie 6.

I am sooooo happy that JK shut up all the Ginny haters on this site by having Harry marry Ginny. HA! To all you Ginny haters! Swallow your dislike for Ginny and GET OVER IT!!!

I know I have probably said this a hundred times, but they had BETTER leave in the Ron/Hermionie kiss. It's just too dang important to cut out!

But I do not think the Harry/Ginny kiss is all that important. I mean, I want it in, but the stupid directors will probably cut it out.

haha wen i posted last i thoguht it was in HBP...yeah so wat i sed doesnt really make sense..i dont really think that they need H/G kiss...but theyl probly include it anyways...

Ron and Hermione's kiss will be in there, no question. It's a huge anticipation for many, including Emma, long showing her support for R/Hr, though she's nervous to kiss Rupert. And my guess is that it will be more or less exactly like it is in the book, having a very Will/Elizabeth-like (from Pirates of the Caribbean) kiss, kissing in the middle of it all.
Ginny and Harry's kiss in her room at the Burrow is a different deal, I think. I could see it being rewritten a little, to include promises, making it more bittersweet than it is in the books. But I would be very surprised if there was kissing with them in the whole movie.
The RiddleHarry/RiddleHermione deal, I don’t know, it really depends on who directs and what they decide to do with that. I'm neutral about seeing the pair of them kiss. I feel no negative feelings because we all know how it ends, who ends up with who and the Horcrux kiss isn't more than a ghost to me. But it might be nice to see because of Dan and Emma's chemistry.

of course the ron and hermione kiss will be there. it is a have to. I dont think the harry and ginny just because they kissed in the last book. and with the ted and victorie maybe depends on the epilogue.

Well they have to think logically which of them is most important and to show that it isn't a romantic war thing. Though love is important in it they don't need Ted and Victorae anyway because if i remember rightly you don't actually see it just James shouting about it.

Ron and Hermione - Quite obviously they have to keep.
Harry and Ginny - Again yes they have to keep.

Obviously important for the epilouge which is the closeing scenes of the whole series and it has to be satisfiying and make sense.

I agree with azkabanical in that the H/G kiss is not that important. With Harry's constant thinking of Ginny and looking at the Maurader's Map to see where she is, this will be enough for the person watching the movie to realize that H/G will get together again.

The R/Hr kiss will certainly be in the movie. It's long time coming for them and the R/Hr shipper.

As for the RiddleHarry/RiddleHermione kiss, this is a very important part in the book and I believe it will be included in the movie. With the chemistry that Dan and Emma share, on and off screen, Warner Bros. will be foolish not to put it in!

Well I think that they should keep
Ha/G
Riddle Ha/Hr
R/Hr

Harry and Ginny I don't think is important but it shows that they still love each other
Riddle Harry and Riddle Hermione I think is very important and it will be awesome with Dan and Emma
Ron and Hermione well let's just sayif it gets left out the director will find a group of about 15 girls (including me) trying to kill him any chance we get

Only fifteen? Au contrare, I believe there will be an army of more then just fifteen... more like 100.... me in the lead.

What the heck are people talking about when they say "Ted/Victoire" kiss? Is that in the English version or something? I live in the U.S.... are they different or something? I don't remember ANYTHING that has to do with "Ted/Victoire" or whatever. Send me an owl just to clarify?

The Ron/Hermione kiss is a MUST! I loved that even after 3 years they finally kiss. You could see it comming but then it finally happened! The Harry/Ginny kiss should be in the movie too. I think it's important because the whole thing of Harry being different is that even after all his loses, he's able to love. He's been in love with Ginny for a while and is still in love with her throughout the whole but, but would rather protect her and sacrife his feelings instead of exposing her. That's beautiful!!! Also, the fact that he kisses her back shows that Harry is human, which is a complete opposite to Voldemort. It should be in the movie!!!
The Teddy/Victoire kiss... I don't think it will be in the movie.... The book only says that it happened, which is something that the directors will take advantage of to make the movie shorter.

The Harry/Cho kiss really bugged me.

Ron and Hermione's will have to be kept in but as its in the middle of the 'war' and the big finale it CANNOT be dragged out

There was also a Harry/Hermione kiss scene in the books. When Ron sees the two of them together (albeit a fabrication of the Horcrux) when he is about to distroy the locket. I don't think it'll make it to the films, but it'd be a pretty cool scene considering the whole events of it (Harry in the pool and whatnot).

Ron/Hermione is pretty much a given, as is Harry/Ginny.

The locket scene, the one where Ron is trying to destroy it, should be in the movie. It plays a pivotal part in the book, and it should in the movie. The evil kiss (as it has become known on another website) scene between Harry and Hermione should also be in the movie as it lets the audience know of Ron's greatest fear - that Hermione loves Harry. If this scene doesn't make it into the final movie, I for one would be disappointed, but most of all, the people in the audience, who don't read the books, will come to understand why Ron never made a move on Hermione before now. So, it's an important scene and it should definitely be included in the final film.

Definetly, but I but I think it'll be like the Maze Task during the Triwizard Tournament in the Goblet of Fire i.e. rushed. In the book, that was a long page, with different riddles and tasks throughout but in the movies, it seemed as though they just ran between a few bushes and that was about it. I think it may be simply cut down .. though I hope not.