If you can get your husband to read it, Amanda, props to you. I can't get any guy to read it!
Anyway, this thread so far has been great! I absolutely adore the responses in here! Yay!
Bella: vampire or human in Breaking Dawn?I really, really hope that Edward decides to change her. I think he's going to keep coming up with excuses as why not to change her, but in the end I think he is going to ultimately do it. Edward is, well, he's a sucker. He's going to give Bella what she wants eventually because that's part of his personality, he lives to please her. There's no way that he can live without her, and she is going to have to die sooner or later. Though, I think the marriage thing will speed everything up. So yes, I think (and hope insanely) that Edward will change her.
Favorite part of the series in the books so far?Oh, I completely adored
Eclipse. I don't know why I liked it so much, but I thought the proposal and all that was way too cute. I also loved the fight sequence between Edward and Victoria. Call me strange, but I probably have that whole thing afterward memorized and can see it in my head way too clearly. Bella just standing there with the shard of rock ready to stab herself, Edward taking down Victoria with Seth. And then when Edward goes back to Bella and you can nearly feel the tension in the air (metaphorically of course...) until Bella trips and he catches her. Which is all too Bella-y and thus why it was perfect!
I also loved the discovery, as you guys have said. And, of course, the meadow.
What do you think of the cast for the movie?I absolutely adore the cast- especially the Cullens! I have to admit, I was a little worried about Robert when I
first heard. Then I thought to myself "
Boy with an adorably crooked smile? Who could pull that off better than Rob Pattinson!" And now I have the fullest faith in Rob. Honestly, breathtaking crooked smile?! *faints*
I'm not sure about how I feel about Kristen as Bella yet. I haven't really seen her act, so I can't judge on that. From pictures, she always just seems a little out of it. Though, I do think that she'll do a great job. The more and more I think about it, I think she'll do an amazing job!
As for the rest of the cast, they've done a great job. For the Cullens, I really think they chose great people. Ashley Greene is the
perfect Alice. She's the one that I am the most confident about. That girl is too cute and too adorable for her own good. Ashley is going to be a great Alice! (I can't even put my thoughts clearly... That's how much I love her!

) Kellan Lutz as Emmett is brilliant, he has that big bear personality but he's still ready to get down to business when necessary- the perfect Emmett. From interviews and whatnot, he seems so funny and just so Emmett-y. Peter Facinelli is Carlisle to a t. He just has that Carlisle aura around him. He's so fatherly, and wise, and... smooth. (

) Nikki Reed definitely looks the part of Rosalie, though she doesn't seem quite as bitter as Rosalie. For those of you who know Jackson Rathbone is going to be Jasper and have seen the pictures, the only thing I can say is this: The hair?!? (

) Elizabeth Reaser I don't know a lot about for Esme... She seems to be the only one we aren't hearing much about. (For us in the Twi-verse) She looks pretty motherly though, which is good. Oh, and I just wanted to say, Micheal Welch for Mike Newton is
exactly how I pictured. And I mean, exactly. It was so creepy... He's going to be great.
Hehe, sorry, I have a lot of opinions on the cast! I'll stop now before I rant more...
Jacob or Edward? Edward.
How did Janet put it?
QUOTE("passerby")
I think Jacob is okay, and he's been a great friend to Bella, but he also works in a very self-serving way. He's manipulative to a point of annoyance with her feelings when he knows how she feels about it. I think he basically tricked her into loving him. . .twisting her feelings all around until she had to admit that she loved him. I don't really have a problem with her having feelings for Jacob because sometimes you just have feelings for people - but I do have a problem with the way he went about forcing it out of her.
Yeah, that was it.

(Janet, it's so not fair that you can put down my thoughts so eloquently

)
What did you guys think of the chapter she's written from Edward's perspective on her site? I think it's fantastic! It was wonderful to get a glimpse into Edward's mind and to understand what
he was feeling upon meeting Bella. I think it's so interesting that we can get little bits and pieces about the others, but Edward is the only one, at least I, can never seem to predict. He seems so much in his own mind, so reserved. It seems like the only person he really, truly trusts is Carlisle. And of course, Carlisle is a stone so Bella would never be able to get information out of him really. I loved hearing what was going through Edward's mind when he saw Bella, it was great! Now we can only hope that they put the quick-publish stamp on it and get it out to us ASAP!
Based on the final chapter of "Eclipse" where she's switched perspectives, do you think the final story will still be from Bella's perspective, from Jacob's, or perhaps a split? How would you feel about it if it were from Jacob's perspective? (I'm getting irritated as I type that, so you can guess what my answer would be!)I think it would be mostly from Bella's, if not all the way. I think the final chapter was really just to give us insight of what Jacob was feeling, as Bella was no longer in contact with him so neither were we. I feel like I read somewhere that if Stephenie manages to extend her contract, she'll write more books about other people from a different perspective, meaning that Bella and Edward's story (though they'll always have their part) will be done.
Now that I'm typing this, though, it makes sense that it would be somewhat of a split. I mean, I can't imagine Bella making up with Jacob so quickly, so we, as the observers, have to get some insight on what Jacob is up to. I don't think I could handle it if Jacob narrated though... On the other hand, she wasn't really talking to him until half way through
Eclipse and that turned out fine, we didn't really need to know what he was doing.
Do you think Carlisle is right about the soul of a vampire?I do, I absolutely, positively agree with Carlisle. You guys have had great responses to this one, so I'll try to keep this out of range of a novella. (As this post seems to be becoming) I just wanted to add that a very wise person once said to me (

) that if someone is truly on the search for
good it doesn't matter what hand their dealt. And I think this is perfectly applicable to this situation.
Now that Victoria and the others are gone, who do you think will be the villain in the next book?[color=#000099]We definitely have Jacob, which is just a problem in and of itself.
Other than that, I think the Volturi are definitely their biggest threat at this point. I think it's incredibly interesting that, although we know Alec's power is to find people. We don't know exactly how far that goes. I think it was somewhere in
New Moon that they referred to him as their "secret weapon". That is oh so interesting to me. We know that he can find something, but I think there is something else to it. Why is he so powerful? Why are he and Jane the terrible twins? I think those questions will be addressed in
Breaking Dawn. Along with Edward fighting Bella over the wedding and Bella fighting Alice over wedding details!
Do you think Bella's sensitivity to blood/the smell of blood will carry over to her vampire state if she's turned? How do you think it will affect her?
This question is really interesting to me and it's definitely something I've thought about since reading the books. I have quite a few theories about it, but I've been writing this post for a while (by the way, if you're still reading it, I love you!) and have some homework to finish so it'll have to wait until tomorrow because I have quite a few things to say about this one!
Oh, and I wanted to bump Anita's questions because I'm curious about them as well! (I'll get to those too! I'm sorry! I'm so busy) And the videos she linked to are
amazing! I have both downloaded and watch them obsessively...
What do you think Bella's power will be, if she gets changed and actually gets one on her vampire life?
Who is your favorite character, and why?