Shiny new thread.....

Basically, just rate the above poster's signature on a scale from 1 to 10, and please explain why you rated it the way you did. All I ask is that you're curteous and respectful, even if your rating is a negative 5.

Have fun! Obviously you can't start with mine...so someone needs to post up!

Ooo, first post goes to me! Yay! Wait, so etphonehome doesn't want hers rated, so I won't rate it. I'll just wait for someone to come along and rate mine!

10...love david cook!

9.5! I love all the icons although I still don't know which musicals some of them are from. Its still coolio, though.

10, I'll explain them to you

Jillyyy! It's a cute layout, and I love the yellow and the way you show us all how much you love Broadway, but I must admit I know nothing about it. And the purple seems a bit... out of place. Faded. 8.5!

Heyyy. Yours is cool. The first one is a wee bit blury/pixely but it still looks cool. And I love the rest of them! Yahooo! And the black coordinates nicely with it. 9!

10! Love the quote, love the guy, love the colors!

Ps. Natchoo, if you want to know the pictures check out he first page of younger Hp fans where I explain the pictures and educate Emma on Broadway!

Pretty sweet. 9!

9.5! Oh I love that cute little dude! It's sooo cute! And the bear! Ahh!

10. hehe your sig made me smile lotsss. :]

I like it. 9

Um... nice quotes and colors, but the alignement is bothering me a bit... I dunno... maybe put like a purple line between them or something? 9

Oooooh Ahhhh. Lovely images! 9.5!

10. i wanna dance with that stickfigure. YO GABBA GABBA <333 (+108932849308094 coolpoints)

I assume they have something to do with Gossip Girl/The Hills or some other one of those shows that are everywhere...? Anyway, I like the pictures, the last one rocks, haha, soo... 9,9. You might want to put the credit under the pictures with the rest...

Thanks, fuzzypeachesplease. I like yours too, although I'm sure it would make a heck of a lot more sesnse If I knew what it was all about . I like the squee-ness though. Squee-ing is awesome! erm....*drumroll* 8!

I love yours. Its so colorful and funny and totally awesome. Although, the pink text is a bit hard to read. 9.5!

10 love the third pic :]

hehe hey emilube [whatssyername ?] and nat. the first two pictures are from south of nowhere. first pic is spencer and ashley. second is spencer and carmen. the last two are blair from gossip girl. haha oh gaah, ive never see the hills..and the promos arent very appealingg :x.

It's cool 10

You added new icons! I like them. Very nice. 9.5!

10. ronaldo <3 imo, he's waay hotter than beckham.

**edit. 10

8. It's full of randomness that I don't even know about. lol.

10! love the pic

Oooo loverly! The colors and images are cute, but I detest Avril Lavigne (sp). No offense. The Colorful quote is cute. So you get a 8.7! Hooray!



P.S. emma_weasley, the pink line says "Pick up that precious something and relax for a delicate few." It's a line from a song I love called "Delicate Few" by O.A.R. (Of A Revolution).

Oh, coolio. I love yours for some reason. It makes me giggle. Mwahahaha! 9.5!

Hehe, I like yours too. You get a very happy......8.8! I like the pirate joke. Pirates rule. And right now I am mentally singing the "Proffesional Pirate" song. I'm not into David Cook, but I'm sure it's important to you. (Well no duh. Four pictures and an avvie dedicated to him reflects importance.)

Hehe. Yes, EMILUBE37, I am quite obsessed with David Cook.

Anyways, I like yours. The dude in the last picture is pretty hot. Just kidding! He's funny looking and makes me giggle every time I see it. 9!

10 david cook!

10 It's pretty cool

Its pretty cool. I love the Dr. Suess quote. Its very true. Not that I've ever been in love. Hehe. And the banner looks nice. 9!

I love your color scheme,and although I won't deny that David is cute, I gotta say he's not my type: 9.5

I like the image and the quote is quite true 9.9

I like it. *coughtoomanyimagescough* So, um, I'll give you an 8.

David Cook!! Um... obsessed much? lol. I like it tho. 9.5!!

You think so? Really? Hehe, yeah I'm waaaay obsessed. Anyways... *ahem* I like the pics in yours. I'm not a huge fan of Harry/Ginny but the other two are nice. 9!

Still love David Cook then? 10

Yep. I still love David Cook. Actually, I'm even more obsessed now that I was a week ago, but that's not the point.

So, I like yours. The banner is cool and it makes me giggle for some reason and I see that you added a couple new icon things. 9!

10

I like it. And I love the random warning that you added. I could say the same thing about myself except I would replace the Broadway with David Cook Hehe. Anyways, your siggy is coolio. 9!

10, hee hee, yes you could,

I like the Broadway theme, it's cute and colourful. I also like the quote, though I usually am not too much for those 'blonde' jokes, but it's still nice. Although the part that says 'warning: broadway' the text is bigger. I don't know if it was intentional, but either way you get a 9!

Actually it's the different fonts I have them in, and it's not meant to be a dumb blonde joke it's just warning people that I'm a bit of a ditz

I like yours, but the pictures are a bit blurry....9

Yours is coolio. And very Broadway-y (yes, I do know what I'm talking about ) 9!

Well of course you know that my siggy is about broadway, ad I gave you a quick Education on broadway... but I did not mention Grease... so ha(JK)

10!

I still like it. Xwahahahaaa! 9.5! The phantom mask is cool.

'Xwahahaha' now that is one evil laugh I have never heard...seen you use before..

10

Broadway!!! 10 Love the phantom mask!!!

Its pretty cool: 9

I really like yours. The banner is awesometastical and I do love the font that you used. And, the Dr. Seuss quote is lovely and true. 9.5!