Here it is- the Master List for the first five books. This will hopefully make threads easier to find and avoid duplicates. The threads in this area are ONLY related specifically to the first five books. Please consult this list (and the other Master Lists) before creating new topics.

For a complete Character Master List, click here


Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone
Can The Mirror Tell the Future?
Dumbeldore and the Secret Keeper
Guarding the Philosopher’s Stone
Harry’s Bed
Hermione’s Lie
The Mirror of Erised
Nitwit, Oddment, Blubber and Tweak
SS/PS General Discussion
PS/SS Questions
Who Voldemort Really Meant to Kill
Why was the House destroyed


Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
Chamber of Secrets General Discussion
Chamber of Secrets Questions
Chamber of Secrets, How Was It Created?
Did Dumbledore know about the diary?
Hagrid Expelled on Riddle’s Word?
Hearing Parseltongue
How did Tom Riddle know about the Chamber of Secrets?
Should Myrtle not have died?
Tom Riddle’s Award
Tom Riddle’s Eyes


Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
How did Fred and George know how to use the Marauders Map?
Moony Prongs Wormtail Padfoot Nicknames Why?
Percy, OWLS and Time Turners
Poa, Dementors Question
Prisoner of Azkaban General Discussion
Time Turners, Loops and Multiple People
Why wasn’t Lupin trusted?


Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
Accio Egg!
Age Restrictions for the Tri-Wizard Tournament
Duelling and Priori Incantatem
Fake Moody and the Imperius Curse
Flesh, Bone and Blood
Gleam of Triump
Goblet of Fire General Discussion
Goblet of Fire Mistakes
Harry Performing Magic in the Graveyard
How did Voldemort Get his Wand Back?
How Do They Know Who Is A Witch Or Wizard?
The Missing Death Eaters
Portkeys in GOF
Polyjuice potion in GOF
The Riddle Family- Who was killed?
The Riddle House
What Voldemort Called Peter
Whose Wand Killed Cedric?
Why couldn’t Harry see the Thestrals earlier?
Why Didn’t Mrs Weasley Check her Clock?


Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
The Advanced Guard
Are there Any Parts that Made You Emotional?
Centeur’s and Umbridge- WANRING: May Disturb Some Readers
Confusing and Befuddlement Draughts
Death Eaters and Wands
Dementors and Dudley
The Detection of Underage Wizardry
Favourite Chapter in OOTP
How Did Voldemort Apparate into the MoM?
How the Order of the Phoenix got its name
In Essence Divided
In the Mind of Ginny Weasley
Is Snape the ‘awful boy’?
Longbottom Theory- About the Gum
Poor Neville- He needs a hug
Ron’s Gift to Hermione
Sirius in OOTP
Sirius’ Funeral
Snape’s Memories
Snape’s Worst Memory
Snape and ‘Remedial Potions
Symbolism of the Phoenix
Things that bother you in OOTP
Umbridge- Did she ruin OOTP for you?
Was OOTP too long?
Why couldn’t Harry see the Thestrals earlier?
Was it really Snape’s Worst Memory?
Why was Malfoy made a Prefect?
Why was Sirius killed?
Why Can't The Ministry Find Sirius Black If Owls Can?
What is the Significance of Sirius's Death?