Cry? as if.

Its not all that sad, especially since there's that shed of hope that he could come back still

He's not out of the race yet, not until the seventh book hits the press.

I won't force my thoughts on others, but I believe that Dumbledore is not coming back, never thought that he'd come back. JKR confirmed it in her last interview that could have been viewed this morning on MSN Video.

I however, always believed that Sirius would end up coming back. He is a marauder, an OTP member, Harry's godfather, and In my opinion, James' best friend, as it has appeared to me.

I never went through the thoughts of him dying and not coming back. If you view all the theories I have corrupted, I have almost always assotiated Sirius becoming alive again. I never did that with Dumbledore, However. I dunno why.

I don't think it'll be dramatic, 'cause the part where Cedric died in GoF wasn't dramatic at all. And I think that that is the most tragic part in the books, Harry's feeling are so well described, and it doesn't show in the movie at all. A bit dissapointing I think. So I really hope they'll make Sirius' death really dramatic and tragic (to make up for GoF) 'cause sirius is one of my favourite characters.

hasnt the new film got the same director because i think all the films have been great

totally agree. i hope its dramatic. just like cedrics
i confess i shedded a few tears about cedric. but
when i read OOTP i actually had tears pouring
down my face. inculding in HBP about dumbledore.

i'll actually cry if its really dramatic. showing harry
getting real angry and remus TRYING to hold him back.
and sirius with his face and eyes and blah blah. falling
into the veil. i'll actually cry over that.

- LYNNLY

No, I don't think I will cry when Sirius dies. I didn't cry in the book, and, in the movie, the only time you see Sirius is when he's on the run from Dementors. I thought he was kind of scary looking! Now that his part blossoms in this movie, I think I will end up crying when he dies. Or maybe I won't. I don't know!
I think that they're going to do it all slow-motion like, but not so that it looks corny. The Gandalf-falls-down-pit scene in Lord of the Rings 1 was the corny kind of slow motion. I laughed through that. It looked hilariously dumb.

I honestly can say I will. I know it for a fact! I cried so much when they showed Cedric die. *shudders*



This is sad, but true. I was so disappointed when Sirius wasn't that influiential in the 4th movie. He was such a big character in the book. So I think that the people who have only seen the movie, but not read the books won't really be that emotional when Sirius dies. Which is sad because all of us will be bawling our eyes out while everyone else is just confused. Poor Sirius! He was my favorite character and I completly drowned myslelf with tears!

I was really disapointed with Siruis's death in the book, because hes such a good charater that you really like. During the fight at the ministry all that really happens is that one min hes fine, then the nexted hes tripped and gone behind the veil, i thought it was such a waste, he should have died fighting or somthing. I hope they make it really sad in the film and dont rush it like they did when Cedric died in GOF- it was too quick and not really sad because you haddnt got to know him. ANYWAY, i want to cry when i see it hehehe

well...sirius was one of my fav. adult figures other than dumbledore. and he was one of the people harry could go to with any problems, even more than dumbledore. i personally hope they make it dramatic to make sure it gets the effect that he is gone and harry will suffer emotionally from this loss.

I don't really know if i'll cry, but i think i'll do... I was about crying when Cedric died although i don't like cedric that much but because i was watching harry feeling so bad and crying, i couldn't stand it.. So, I think i'll cry, but i don't know why, because of Sirius's death, or because of Harry's reaction and sadness....

i think i'm going to cry when it happens i know i did when i read it EH? you? i think they'll make it reallly dramadic like they put it in slow-mo and cut the sound or somthing like that somthing that you'll now whats about to happen and somthing you won't forget, some thing that will make the emotionle people to cry or the people who go on the sirius black is hot website lol

what do you girlz think? (or guys) lol

Oh my God
Even I wouldn't cry during Harry potter.
If Harry Can Take It So Can I!

Bye!!!!!!

I didn't cry when SIRIUS died but i did when DUMBLRDORE died... It was only a few tear drops! I've never cried over a book before though.

About SIRIUS. Hmmm... I think he should die in slow motion like a few other people said, and then one tear runs down harry's face. He falls to his knees, and sees BELLATRIX running away. He gets up and tears away from LUPIN. yada yada yada. Go on with the rest of the story.

hmmmm
when sirius dies, of course they are going to make it dramatic! this is television/movies!
plus... it is a sort of emotional thing and slay, your version of what will happen, sounds pretty much like what i imagine will happen

Oh god, when I read the ending to book 5 I started crying, I really don't like the fact that he's never coming back. It will be dramatic it has to be, they have to give that amazing character a wonderful way to go down!

I agree with Zyra that it will be a big ordeal... I've got a feeling Harry's emotional response to Sirius's death might even be a part of the trailer whenever it comes out. It will definitely be a good selling point for the movie and probably bring in a few more people than expected.

Gee, I don't think it will be part of the trailer because for those not reading the books, it will be/should be a surprise that Sirius is killed.

yah i think it'll be something unforgetable and make you like cry or something like it'll be like in slow-mo and they'll cut the sound kind of what they did in narnia when the white witch stabbed edmond i don't know if you all remember that if you wanted to see that movie and didn't and i spoiled it for you im so so sorry but i ahd to suport my theory.

yeh. hopefully it'll be supa drama. slow motion and stuff. if not i'll be real upset coz its major.if Harry starts crying i'll start laughing. not to sat Sirius death is something to laugh about jst that Harrys ment to be all hero and junk and crying is kinda soft if hes going to be fighting Bellatrix and death - eaters...

i have no doubt it will be incredibly sad leaving people in tears around the world. so yes i think the director will make that part of teh film as dramatic as possible

They had better make it significant in the movie because it is a pretty sad thing. My theory is that when people get sad in a movie they go to see it again, sometimes, and that gets them more money...so it will probably be a big scene. And Harry made a big deal about it so there will have to be at least five to ten minutes about it...

They had better actually make at least a emdium deal out of it. not like the biggest deal of the movie but still a big one.

I cried a lot when i read of Sirius' death... He's my favourite character... so it's a very sad life... without his godfather and his parents... poor harry!! eeee

i´m a bit afraid of seeing the scene of sirius´death in the next movie.
i was shocked as i read it and i also had to cry ( i normally don´t cry for characters in movies or books!).
i think they´ll put this event in the right mood to feel very sad... with background music and harry screaming for his godfather...

I think it will be very dramatic and sad to all who have read the book...of course it will look like a heroes death and i think they will show harry sort of make an attempt at saving him but not get there quite in time or something

I think it will be very dramatic.

Andit will be better for thosse who haven't read the books because they'll only think he has fallen like Harry..
So it should be really dramatic i don't know if it will be worst tham Cedric's death though.

I am not sure that his death will be that dramatic. I mean, if you consider how fast it happened in the book then I am not so sure. I could see the director making the whole battle scene a tad dramatic, but there isn't much they can do with Sirius's death unless they want to go against the book completely and have him shout out some last words or something, which would bother me a bit because that isn't how the story is suppose to go. Oh, and I really hope they don't make his fall slow and dramatic, that would take away from the effect of his death I think. Not to mention the fact that the marauders are my favorite characters and I about died when he died in the book ( ) I don't want to have to watch him die slow and painfully. His death is sad enough with the dramatics!

This is the major scene in the movie!!! its got to be scary and dramatic, i guess it might be slow motion and the atmosphere will be very tense, but i disagree with the ratings they'll give the movie it cantt be higher than pg15!!

they even, said that stuff about ratings even with the 4th movie , they said it wuz scary, but when i saw it, there wuz nuthin scary about it!!!

I hope it's not too slow either, HP_RULES, you're right about how if the fall is stretched for extra drama it could take away from the written passage's effect. The moment it happens, Harry's on the ground amidst a half dozen duels and then he sees the crucial second of Sirius leaving. If they use creative license like in previous adaptations for the big scenes (Quirrell rising up to choke Harry, the Basilisk sniffing hearing for HP in the sewer line, Hermione throwing rocks in the time travel sequence, etc.), I personally would be enthralled if they altered to background noise of chaos to convey Harry looking for his godfather just before it occurs. They could ebb the duelling noises so it feels almost out of step with the action then as we see Sirius falling, all we hear would be the veil fluttering. Would that be too dramatic?

definitely yes! i think sirius' death would be very dramatic! and i was thinking that i'll cry the whole day after watching the film!

I, personally, am very emotional when it comes to subjects I care about and will definitely cry my eyes out in the movie. I cried in Goblet of Fire the book when Cedric died and when Harry was in pain, and I cried for the same scenes in the movie. I cried in the Order of the Phoenix when Sirius died, and I will definitely cry for the movie.

So, that being said, I extremely hope that they do make Sirius's death dramatic and pay him tribute. After all, he won't be acting in the series any more after that, unless JKR totally forgets her sense of writing and writes that in the next book.

I certainly hope they give it enough drama that it's a good scene, because it is a VERY important scene. And yes, I do think I'll cry, as I cried in the book as well. Sirius is very dear to me, and I absolutely hate Harry losing him so suddenly, so abrubtly. And if that idiot Kreacher hadn't made Harry think that Sirius was in trouble... it never would have happened.

Git.

Regards,
BTV

No, that would be perfect. It would be slightly reminiscent of the movie Return of the King, when Gandalf is fighting outside the Black Gates, and he stops fighting, the background blurs, and only he and the Moth that flutters across the screen are in perfect clarity. The background noise drops significantly and the soft music was being played. If they can pull off something similar, where there is little sound but for soft music, as sirius falls through the Veil, and you can hear the definite flapping of the Veil material itself.... perfect!

~Albus

In the books, it's just the right amount of drama to be real. I'm betting in the movie, they'll make it really over-dramatic and OTT.

Stupid movies. Books are better.

I think it should be very dramatic && sad.
As Sirius falls through the veil it should be all slow motion && silent - you know.

I know for a fact that I am going to cry when Sirius dies because i did when I read the book && I was really upset lol. I do hope they make it dramatic && don't just rush through it.

^^^Thats what i hope they DON'T do.That would make it seem so stupid just having like everyone stare in silence although i bet they will do that. I just hope they dont change a huge part in it. I can imagine them having Voldemort appear out of nowhere and push sirius into the veil . They better not screw it up atleast.


-----SITH-----

It should be sad, but you never know with movie producers. Some people will probably make it wierd and not emotional at all.

i can't wait for that section of the movie as well!!!!!
i hope they make a big deal out of it and every one cries!!! it'll be really emotional and everything i'll need to bring a box of tissues!!

I hope they make it really dramatic! In the book it's very dramatic so it should be in the movie as well. It should be very emotionally heart wrenching as well ... that way the audience sort of understands Harry's pain.

omg, I so agree, it should be very heart-breaking and create an atmosphere of loss & failure, cause that's pretty much how I felt when I read the scene. I really hope that they don't stuff this up, cause it's a very dramatic part...

DUH, the movie guys are gonna make the death dramatic. these guys do anything to make more money!

Lots of you are hoping that the it will be dramatic s. As i said before of coures the scene will be dramatic. When don't the movie dudes overdramaticize certain scenes found in book? Personnally i think making it too dramatic will make me sadder than if it were just very quick.

I think the scene should be dramatic. Sirius is the closest thing to a father Harry has ever had. Therefore,(it is in my opinion) that the scene should be depressing.

I think the scene will be in slow motion and all the sound will have gone to make it more dramatic and then after its happened the sound will come back on really suddenley to make it even more dramitic and to show the amount of emotion there is.

I think that the scene will be just like the book says Sirius will be fighting Bella and then she will push him through the vail and then Harry will scream SIRIUS! and Lupin will stop him from nearly jumping after him so I deffenately think it will be dramatic. I cried so mutch when Sirius died in the book and I have a feeling I will cry more during the movie. I Sirius!

I think that when Sirius dies in the movie it will be very dramatic because is the big thing in the movie.

No slow motion! I don't want to watch Sirius die slowly. Though it would look cool. Like in X-Men 3 when Jean kills Proffesor X everything slows down and the camera revolves so you see everything Xavier says something then he explodes.
They could do the same kind of thing with Sirus but that would be worse then a quick death.
This is going to be depressing.

knowing warner bros. Definately! I mean, sirius was a pretty significant character in the books; so yea, naturally it would make sense for his death to be dramatically viewed...personally, i do hope that it is drmatically and heroically portrayed, but not too emotional, cause that'd just be a bit boring...

Yeah sometimes too emotional is boring an dyour sitting there 'Come on we're flipping bored over here get over it and stop being a baby.' Or at least that's along the lines I've thought lol. I really hate sad movies. DD's desth in HBP won't bother me as much as Sirius' because I like Sirius a lot more than DD.

^^^ i know what u mean. I hope they dont make it so dramatic that you are like come on Harry stop being a baby about it. Dont be suprised though if it goes into like slow - mo and there is no sound. I hope they make it like the LoTR, where boromir gets killed. They still have some sound but it is toned down. Thats how they should have Sirius die.

-----SITH-----

I agree with Sith/RedSkin that they will have it like slow motion like in the Lord of the Rings where Boromir dies in kind of a slow motion type of deal. But if they have it that Sirius dies in a kind of slow motion type of deal, I think i'm going to cry because i almost cried when i read that part in the book. but overall i think that i'm going to cry either way: slow motion or not.



*Sirius*

Yeah it probably will be in slow motion. That'd be okay as long as they don't draw it out forever and a day. Having it be like Boromir would be good. They could have Lupin draggind Harry and Neville out of the room while you only hear a little sound. Hmm I can picture that easily.
Poor Sirius.
*X-Girl*