passerby
Aug 1 2007, 04:29 AM
Just a note to new players and old players: If you include any DH what if questions, your post MUST CONTAIN spoiler tags! If you are unsure how to use them, DO NOT POST until you have contacted a staff member for a small tutorial! Please abide by this rule or your posts will be deleted. Thanks!
KingSimbaII
Aug 17 2007, 11:11 PM
Here are some of mine:
1.What if Harry had listened to Dobby and not gone to Hogwarts for his second year?
2.What if Voldemort felt that the prophecy refered to Nevile and himself?
3. What if Merope Gaunt had never died while giving birth to Tom Riddle Jr.?
4.What if Harry didn't ask the sorting hat not to put him in Slytherin which relulted in Harry being in Slytherin?
5. What if Sirius had told Harry what was in that package he gave him (the two-way mirror) before going back to school, which would make Harry contact Sirius when he saw those visions of him (Sirius) being tortured by Lord Voldemort?
clarisa
Aug 17 2007, 11:20 PM
All spoilers I'm afraid.
» Click to Show Spoiler - Click Again to Hide... «
What if dumbledore explained himself to everyone? What if Severus didn't love Lily? What if James didn't love Lily? You can see wheer this is going....[spoiler/]
Sugar N Spice
Aug 25 2007, 04:20 AM
What if there
was no Voldemort?
No.1_HarryPotterFan
Aug 29 2007, 09:56 PM
If there was no Voldy, then we would all be reading a series about a boy who was a wizard with no real subplot... oh, the horrors!!

What if Sirius and Dumbledore never died?
gryffindorgirlie
Sep 16 2007, 04:18 PM
Ahhhh.. I'd put a gun to my head!
What if you drpped your Deathly hallows in the bath the day you got it! It's ruined forever!
No.1_HarryPotterFan
Sep 16 2007, 10:40 PM
I'd buy another one.
What if JKR was never born? (dun dun DUN)
Radcliffegirl07
Oct 1 2007, 03:57 AM
I'd be all depressed. That would be horrible! Now I'm going to have nigthmares about that.
What if Voldemort still had a nose? (sorry it is dorky)
No.1_HarryPotterFan
Oct 1 2007, 11:29 PM
Then he'd look normal
What if Daniel Radcliffe was in a car accident?
Radcliffegirl07
Oct 2 2007, 12:21 AM
I'd be bawling my eyes out and screaming that I NEED to get to England to check on the hottest guy on Earth. I would be a wreck!
What if...
Rupert quit filming HP?
ali_kisskiss
Oct 2 2007, 12:21 AM
well he'd be injured for a while, postponing the filming of hbp. well if he died in it theyd get a new harry.
what if dumbledor never helped snape help him?
Radcliffegirl07
Oct 2 2007, 12:37 AM

then dumbledore wouldn't have had help from snape because snape didn't have help from Dumbledore....
What if Rupert wasn't able to film the last two HP's?
ali_kisskiss
Oct 2 2007, 01:19 AM
they probably would have gotten a new ron.
what if hagrid and grawps mom never existed. would the story be very veryy different?
No.1_HarryPotterFan
Oct 13 2007, 07:30 PM
Then we wouldn't have found out about the Sorcerer's stone!
What if Hermione was in Ravenclaw?
fantasiefantic
Oct 13 2007, 11:33 PM
thay could never have made polyjuice potion
what if james or oliver phelps

died
No George without Fred
Feb 26 2008, 02:17 AM
I would

cry

my eyes out for weeks and weeks...
What if Percy married Cho?What if Dementors
Celebrated Valintines Day?What if Whalebertoung was the ability to talk to whales?What if Ron died? What
if Harry
died?What if Hagrid died?What if Hedwig and Pig were secritly dating?What if Trevor is an animagus?What if Nevillle is resorted into Ravenclaw?What if Dudly marries Hermione?What if Mrs. Figg uses love potion to get Filch away Madam Pince but and than Filch gets married to Mrs. Figg and they have a kid and they name him Harry Potter and Voldimort mistakes him for Harry James Potter when he is really Harry Santa Potter after Santa Clause who is Mrs. Figgs second cosion twice removed on her second adoptive dads side?(sorry...I couldn't help myself...I'll go now...)
The Writing on the Wall
Feb 27 2008, 08:48 PM
1) Harry would think 'What an Odd couple.' Percy would understand Quidditch and Cho would get annoyed by his pompous demeanour and divorce him.
2) It would be very mist on Feb 14th
3) Dory of Finding Nemo can speak Whalebertoung!
4) Hermione would be heart-broken, Harry would be upset, Mrs. Weasley would cry a lot, Ginny would be the same.
5) Then there would be an Earthquake when he the floor
6) Owl babies...
7) Then he obviously doesn't like the wizard who adopted him!
8) Then Pigs fly, and without Wingardium Leviosa or wings.... or a cannon.
9) Then Santa Claus would be coming.. to town. Soory, also could not help myself, my questions...
What If Mcgonagall said 'I'm having a baby, and it's yours' to Harry?
What If Mcgonagall said 'I'm having a baby, and it's yours' to Hagrid?
What If Norberta said 'Roar' (I'm having a baby, and it's yours) to Hagrid?
What If Lemons over took the wizards as wand-holders?
What if Goblins made Slytherin a Sword?
What if Ragnok the first is actually Griphook in disguise?
What if Harry got Transfigured into a goat by Aberforth and was charmed in strange ways?
Killian
Feb 27 2008, 09:08 PM
What If Mcgonagall said 'I'm having a baby, and it's yours' to Harry?
She'd be spending a nice little spell in Azkaban.
What If Mcgonagall said 'I'm having a baby, and it's yours' to Hagrid?
She'd be having Hagrid's baby.
What If Norberta said 'Roar' (I'm having a baby, and it's yours) to Hagrid?
It'd be a scientific miracle.
What If Lemons over took the wizards as wand-holders?
Wizards would overthrow them.
What if Goblins made Slytherin a Sword?
Godric's sword would still have been made I presume so not much difference to the storyline.
What if Ragnok the first is actually Griphook in disguise?
Griphook turned out as he did - regardless.
What if Harry got Transfigured into a goat by Aberforth and was charmed in strange ways?
He'd be a goat.
What if there was no colour blue?
harry_potter_luvr_4life
Feb 27 2008, 09:12 PM
QUOTE(Radcliffegirl07 @ Oct 1 2007, 07:21 PM) [snapback]452779[/snapback]
I'd be bawling my eyes out and screaming that I NEED to get to England to check on the hottest guy on Earth. I would be a wreck!
What if...
Rupert quit filming HP?

That would stink. I agree with you on the Daniel thing. That would be awful. I would probably get out my college savings account and fly to England to see him like you.
And the Mcgonagall thing. OMG..... That would kill me. Wow. The thought is scaring me... Owwww..... get the thought out of my head!!!!! Please!!!!!!
HP'sPrincessFiona
Feb 28 2008, 05:08 AM
QUOTE(Killian @ Feb 27 2008, 01:08 PM) [snapback]489803[/snapback]
What if there was no colour blue?
Then Smurfs would not exist, the sky would be magenta, and the ocean would be orange.
What if JK Rowling ruled the world? (That's not to say that she doesn't
already 
)
ILoveHarryPotter07
Mar 1 2008, 06:15 PM
Then there would be a World Wide Harry Potter Day.
And she could come on tv every night and read the world a bedtime story! That would be awesome.
What if...Voldemort didn't die??
Sirren
May 29 2008, 04:34 PM
If Voldemort didn't die, we'd be waiting for the next installment of Harry Potter right now!
What if the series wasn't over and another book was coming out?
emma_weasley
May 29 2008, 08:02 PM
I would be jumping up and down and being waaaay too excited. And I'd be rereading the series for the squintillionth time.
What if Neville and Luna had gotten together?
What if everyone died at the end excpet Voldemort?
What if Voldemort was forced to work as a muggle toymaker and was stripped of all magical powers?
cupcake
May 29 2008, 10:22 PM
if luna and neville got together...then they would be a happy couple and i would be happpy 4 them
if everyone died at the end expept voldy, then i would soak the pages of DH with tears... OR we all would be waiting for revengeeeee in another boooookkkk
if voldy was forced to work as a toymaker then i would be happppppyyyyy! that would be so funny dudeeee...
What if harry died?
what if dumbledore hadnt died??^ya i know what your thinking, "she's dead depressing! talking about peple dying!"

~totally hyped up... mehh
rach2603
Aug 13 2008, 03:57 PM
if DD hadnt of died- there would be no rumour that his funeral had been cut fromt he movie- and i wouldnt have had it ruined by the radio DJ saying that he died before i read it
What if.... dbby didnt like socks???
sadie_urlady523
Oct 15 2008, 06:44 PM
The world would never be the same agian. And his feet would get cold.
What if Ron had actually married Lavender?
bookworm_1918
Oct 18 2008, 12:11 AM
THATD BE SCARY!! Haha I don't like Lavender so I'd have to say I'd be pretty mad about that...and I think Hermione would agree with me
What if Fred survived?
sadie_urlady523
Oct 19 2008, 11:39 AM
Then I'd scream with joy, and then Weasley Wizard's Wheezes would've gone on for a long time.
What if Malfoy had never attended Hogwarts?
Norberta
Oct 19 2008, 07:21 PM
Then he would have attended durmstrang and found himself a new guy to pick on: Harrymir Potterslav
What if Harry and Hermione had married??
DracosLady
Oct 20 2008, 11:42 PM
Then Ron and Harry's friendship would be over since Ron and Ginny would both be angry and heartbroken as well
What if Malfoy and Dumbledore killed Snape out of Revenge?
sadie_urlady523
Oct 21 2008, 01:02 AM
Then I'd hate the books.
What if Dumbledore married Professor McGonagall?
bookworm_1918
Oct 23 2008, 06:47 PM
That'd be a BIT awkward, actually...I wouldn't like that!!
What if...Ginny rejected Harry in HBP?
Sirren
Oct 23 2008, 06:50 PM
I wouldn't have cared, because I'm not that great a fan of that relationship.
What if Snape would have died when he returned to Voldemort in OOTP?
DracosLady
Oct 25 2008, 12:16 PM
Then Harry would not have been saved because Snape saved his keister by sacrificing himself to Voldy...
What if Hermione had fallen for Draco and they had gotten married ?
Sirren
Oct 25 2008, 12:21 PM
That would have been the end of Draco, because Lucius would have killed him himself.
What if Ron and Luna had fallen in love in HBP and stayed together?
Snapefan21
Oct 25 2008, 07:04 PM
Then Hermione would fall for Snape, leading to a very odd ending
What if Snape had caught the trio making Polyjuice potion in second year?
honey~pie
Oct 30 2008, 12:24 PM

then the trio would have never found out that Malfoy wasn't the heir... and they'd get expelled
What if the HP books were about Neville? and how his parents had been killed? And how he'd have to kill off Voldie?
DracosLady
Oct 31 2008, 10:19 PM
Then Neville would be the Boy Who Lived and Harry would be the Witless Wonder of Gryffindor, and Neville would be the Tri Wiz Champ and marry Ginny, and Harry would be stuck with Luna Lovegood....
What if Crabbe had been the leader of Slytherin and Malfoy had been his cronie?
DeSs
Nov 3 2008, 09:33 PM
Then Crabbe would have been forced to become a Death Eater and he would have gone every where saying: "Ooh, look, I've got a Dakt-Makr ... And I'm with Long Voldimon!" And he would have killed the trio in the Requirement Room, and he wouldn't have died... or,yes, he would.
What if Lavender had dated Harry instead of Ron?
Norberta
Nov 8 2008, 12:07 PM
Then Ron and Hermione would have went to slughorns party together and they would have ended up as a couple much sooner, and everyone would have been a lot happier. Except for maybe Ginny!
What if Dumbledore had survived HBP?
DeSs
Nov 26 2008, 04:44 PM
Then he could have helped Harry a lot more, and carry on together with the hunting for the Horcrux, but Hary wouldn't have learnt a lot.
What if Harry had drown in the Forest of Dean?
sadie_urlady523
Nov 27 2008, 01:36 AM
Then the story would pretty much end there and JK Rowling had better watch out.

What if there were 20 horcruxes?
Pearl the Barrister
Dec 22 2008, 03:24 PM
The series would either take millions of books to end or some sort of deus ex machina crud would happen and everyone would live happily ever after.
Or, Voldemort would win, because it would take forever to find 20 horcruxes. And destroy them, too.
What if Lily hadn't given her life to save Harry?
parisg
Dec 23 2008, 04:09 PM
The series would be called Neville Longbottom not Harry Potter and would in turn be all about Neville
What if Snape wasn't a spy
LadyMalfoy
Dec 23 2008, 05:48 PM
Then, Harry wouldn't have felt bad about his death and named on of his children Albus Severus.
What if Draco married Pansy?
DeSs
Feb 1 2009, 04:05 AM
Then everything have changed for me.
What if Draco had killed Dumbledore himself?
zwillo
Feb 28 2009, 10:31 PM
Then Voldemort would have killed him in the shrieking shack instead of Snape to gain control of the Elder wand.
What if Hermione had never bought Crookshanks?
rebel_megz
Feb 28 2009, 10:36 PM
She wouldn't have fought with Ron all the time.
What if Draco and Hermione dated?
NKIqbal
Mar 4 2009, 09:39 PM
Then Ron would have an even bigger reason to hate Draco and his family!!!
What if Mad-Eye Moody lived???
zwillo
Mar 7 2009, 02:13 PM
Then Harry, Ron and Hermione would have had no problems getting out of the ministry undetected, because Harry wouldn't have stolen his eye off of Umbridge's door.
What if Harry hadn't been neglected and abused when he was growing up?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.