Which of these fantasy worlds would you love to be part of? Some people are just wired for different earths, or different universes. Fall into Hogwarts, Middle Earth, or Narnia, and pick your fancy.

The only reason why I would like to go to Middle Earth is Legolas. But as he gave his heart to the sea, I gave up every hope!! Serioysly now, I already feel a part of Hogwarts, so my transportation there would just complete the illusion..

I love Hogwarts because there's all these secret passage ways and stuff. Wouldn't it be exciting to explore Hogwarts and the grounds without dying the first five minutes in? Cha!

Definately the age in which the tv program Xena:Warrior Princess because i think its great fighting with swords and shields and in Xena's case chakrams.

Ooooooooooooooo Tough one. Ok i Voted for Other as i like Philip Pullmans Dark Materials.

Because I just think the different versions of earth are really cool and just for all you people who havn't read them its a bit like infinitie there are infinitie versions of earth in this book so there is bound to be a Harry Potter one and any other fantasy world you have read thats why i like it so much!!!

(im also a big fan of StarGate and a little of Star trek so i like my fantasy as do you all as we all ended up on this website talking about a fantasy)

I voted the all one. I would love to go to any of em! I mean Middle Earth because of that one hottie Aragon or whats his name? (sp) yeahhh hes a babe teehee. But i also want to go to hogwarts coz that would be soooo fun! but hogwarts is only a place for kids i wouldnt want to teach there...unless i was like headmistress. but also the narnia place is cool too coz there are like talking beavers and other cool things! So yeah i want to go to them all yayness!

I voted for Hogwarts, as there's magic there. I know there's magic other places too, but at Hogwarts you learn magic, do magic and love magic! Oooh, no other alternatives

Love, Caoo

Oh man, you give me a tough decision, I love the HP world and Middle Earth. Both are of my two favorite books, but I think I would choose the HP world with Hogwarts. I mean, Hogwarts would be the most amazing school to go to, every night I would go to bed, I would be soooo excited for the next day.

Although, I don't mind our world either, I would miss friends and family a lot if I were to switch to another world.

well the world that i would love to be imersed in would be Harry potter but the setting and story i perfer is lord of the rings, simply because i think its s o awesome to read something taht could have happened a long time ago rather then now.

-Sarah

Hogwarts all the way! Narnia is a little bit...weird you know...Anyways, Hogwarts is so friggen col! You get wands and poke people's eyes out. ;P

If I had to choose, I'd choose Hogwarts. I would want to teach, not be a student.

If I lived in Hogwarts, where would I retreat into a fantasy world for relief from daily stress?

Wait, do you go to Middle Earth during peace or war? 'Cause I don't think it'd be too great of an idea to visit while orcs are running around. But I would DEFINATELY go to Hogwarts. Sadly, I'm a Muggle so I'd just see a sign that says something like, "Keep Off" and a castle in ruins. *sigh*

I seriously dunno why you posted this PLEASE NO OFFENCE its just its preety obvious Hogwarts will hav most, i mean comon this is a HP site 4 cryin out loud!!!!!!!

This is a tough one. But my heart lies in middle earth. It's absolutely beautiful.

MOD EDIT: please be careful one liners are not allowed on the forums..please elaboratre more in future posts!

Hogwarts rulezzz... Hogwarts 4 ever!

MOD EDIT: please be careful one liners are not allowed on the forums..please elaboratre more in future posts!

Alagaesia is the best fantasy world!!! The Inheritence Trilogy rocks!!!

Please have a look at the rules..one liners are not allowed on the forums..please elaborate more in future posts!

Well, for me, it's about a tie between Hogwarts and Alagaesia. Many have not yet taken into account that there is a new fantasy epic on our doorsteps! Eragon, Eldest, and the unknown last installment of the Inheritance trilogy are a force to be reckoned with!

Hogwarts still has that one special place in my heart and still is my true favorite, but I am begining to love the fantasy world of Alagaesia as well!

As for Middle Earth and Narnia, I do love The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, but it seems to be a bit of a book for younger children to me now... Narnia still is an excellent place for magic.

Middle Earth is a work of genius and very highly developed, but I simply cannot get through The Fellowship of the Ring. Perhaps if I could somehow get into that book (which isn't likely) it could grow to be my favorite. But for now, I will stick the the movie form of Middle Earth.

New Post:

** I'm glad to see that someone else on this forum likes Alagaesia too! I didn't notice at first. Go Saphira!! ^^

Hi everyone, I voted for Hogwarts is the ultimate fantasy world, because of all the magic and everything, just think what you could do.

HermioneWeasley2.

Please have a look at the rules..you have been here long enough to know that one liners are not allowed on the forums..please elaborate more in future posts! also your siggy is WAY to long the most it can be is five lines please fix this as soon as possible

I would jump into any of them at any time. All these places have their own advantages and disadvantages.

ADVANTAGES

Hogwarts: Completely magical, you can do anything, make anything, eat anything and be anyone. You have all the resources you need at the end of your wand. With the protection and skills as well as the magical people and knowledge and irradically secluded - sometimes being alone is a good thing.

Middle Earth: Beautiful landscapes (ooh especially rivendale and the woods and Moria. Between elves and Hobbits and Dwarves the people selection is great. THe land is vast and mysterious and anythign could happen. YOu could go anywhere, live where you want, when you want with who you want, there are no secrets.

Narnia: a beautiful land of talking creatures and mystical beings as well as fairy tale lives and happiness always. It's not everyday you get to talk to giants and fauns and centaurs and talking birds, lions, cats, and even beavers. Even the trees talk to yah. You could leave, live a full life and come back to your age, HHMMM I wonder how many times you could do that????

DISADVANTAGES

Hogwarts: THe palce is hidden fromt eh rest of the world, the interaction with muggles must be limited and all you'll ever know is magic, what about the rest of the world, being hidden doesn't sound like the ultimte fantasy, but it does sound like a good one.

Middle Earth: Too many wars on land ownership and power struggles. The creatures here could be found in other places I suppose, and life would not be as easy as it would be in Narnia or Hogwarts. Although the elves are ravishing and the land is vastly shared this fantasy is only a good one.

Narnia: You seen one pretty landscape you seen them all. Since everything has a mind of its own and most can talk, the privacy level would be at a minimum. You can only take a talking tree and beaver so much before insanity hits. The privacy issue is what makes this fantasy only a good one.

So, If I could go into any of them at any time yo give myself a variety, together thet would make the ultimate fantasy land...

I would love to go to Hogwarts to be with Harry .

Please have a look at the rules..one liners are not allowed on the forums..please elaborate more in future posts!

Oooo!!

This was very hard for me to pick... I love them all very much!

Narnia: Has Peter...mmm....high king Peter. *drools* And it has Aslan. Aslan rocks...and Reepicheep! Reepicheep is like, the best Narnia character! Nearlly... and its got amazing animals and talking beasts!

Hogwarts: Well you get to be a witch or wizard if you go there... So thats nice. it also has the room of requrment, wich is realy cool. And its got Ron..so.. And Pheonixes! They rock! Alot!

Middle Earth: Elves...haha...yeah, they rock. Mainlly Legolas! And you cant forget that its absolutlly amazing to the eyes! The hills that go on forever, the castles, talking trees (now thats just gnarlly!) and many more things!

I thought this all over...and I went with *drum roll*:
Middle Earth! Because elfs, rual!

oh i love narnia the books are great, they are really good. middle earth are really good too. but i chose hogwarts. harry potter inspired me to read books and taught me alot. i would pick that because hogwarts should go down in history.

harry potter is the only book i've read out of the three choices... and i know nothing about middle earth and i've only watched the narnia (lion, witch, and wardrobe) movie

so of course i had to pick hogwarts... every time i read the books, i can imagine i'm sitting next to harry, ron, and hermione inside of hogwarts

hogwarts is so magical and breathtaking that i wish i could enter the world i imagine everytime i read the books

Obviously Hogwarts, I love everything about it! It's the must realistic, brilliant, complex,..., one. I mean that it can really exist and I would like that.

I voted saying that I would go to any world. Now, I think I would be stuck between going to Hogwarts and Narnia. I love the animals and different seasons in Narnia, but I love the magic at Hogwarts. I think I would favor Narnia because of the hose/human things. I'm a stickler for horse related beings. Sad really, but true. But, in Hogwarts they have unicorns. I could pet one and ride it. Oh... too bad they don't really exsist.

Tah
HoofsTails Gal

id prefer hogwarts! honestly its just perfect! its not too out of this world..as opposed to the other two..i would probablly go insane in middle earth or narnia..or even end up dead..haha..but hogwarts is just fine with me..how i wish i was really in hogwarts though..

As much as I would love to visit Hogwarts or Narnia, I chose Middle-Earth because I would love to visit all the Elven cities like Rivendell and Lothlorien.

Definitely Middle-Earth. I'm obsessed with LotR. Its just so beautiful. I've seen and read the movies and books so many times I feel like I've been there. I love all the characters, especially the hobbits and Aragorn. I dont like Legolas that much because Orlando Bloom's portrayal pretty much ruined him for me.

Its hard to choose though, I would love to come to Hogwarts!!! But as I said above, I've also read Harry Potter so many time I feel I've been there.

I also love Narnia, even though I haven't read the books as many time as I have LotR and Harry Potter.

It would have to be Hogwarts, as I've never been so obsessed with a fictional world as I have with this one.

Narnia... I used to like those books when I was a kid, but not as much now. It feels kind of weird when I read them now, like I'm betraying HP by reading other fantasy books.

Middle Earth is something that has been kind of ruined for me. I find it highly overrated, and a lot of people I know only like it because "Like, omg, Legolas is sooooo, like, hot!!!!1111" or because they're know-it-alls by nature, and they think that saying they like LotR will make them seem so hip and educated and different. Rarely do I find anyone who likes it because it's high-quality literature.

Well, in the last 4 years, I was daydreaming everyday about mddleearth. Hey, what's hotter than aragorn??? What a pity, he's dead... Legolas is also cool, but orlando seems a bit gay in the movie (sorry at all orli- fans^^) and actually, legolas gave his heart to the sea (v v no luck today...)
I really admire Tolkien.
But after you've seen the lotr movies the 10000000 time, they become boring. READ THE BOOKS, PEOPLE!!
So far, so good ^^
Harry Potter is defenitely on second place! I just LOVE the books. I keep reading them every month ^^. They're less difficult to read than lotr, that's more fun.

Narnia: well i've seen the movie, but i'm not convinced at all. The books are good, but they're real children's books

@ vindictive dark
I totally agree with that what you said about people who say they like lotr just to seem cool,even if they havent read the books

I dunno coz i always thought that i should hav liked in the 3rd age of middle earth or in alagaesia during the conquest of the dragon riders when the empire was nothing but a speck of dust until the evil king becided 'i dont like these elves and dwarves so i am going to be a rebel and hijack the system so i cam become king coz im evil )

tough...very tough.

I have always been an avid fantasy lover, and even though I have much love for middle earth, Hogwarts has recenly come to be that home away from home, due to JKR's writing ability.

i cant decide, but if i wanted to stay me, id say Hogwarts, because id be useless as a human in Middle earth..cant ride a horse to save my life.

the best is Hogwarts, it's more interesting than the others. But I have to recognize that Narnia's world has a lot of mysteries and all... And the Middle Earth nothing , i don't like it at all..
1.Hogwarts
2.Narnia

I choose the only one country where I can find Legolas! So I choose the Middle Earth!
Malefica :-)

Gee, I dunno. I like all of the fantasy worlds, but I gues I like Harry Potter the most since it is the most I can identify myself with. LOTR has orcs and elves and stuff, and narnia they go to a different land. I guess HP is the only one who has normal kids in it.

I only read a bit of the Lord of the Rings series, and Middle Earth seems scary. You never know if you'll run in to an orc or maybe even Saruman! Ugh. {shiver} I knew I would say HP world, because it's not as bloody and brutal as Middle Earth, and it's a bit better than Narnia. Don't get me wrong, I love Narnia, but Harry Potter tops everything.

I honestly wouldn't mind jumping into any of these worlds cos they are all soo magical in their own ways!Narnia being that there is talking animals,Middle Earth being that there is Legolas and Hogwarts cos I love HP and I am soo used to it!But,a little secret,shhh...I prefer Hogwarts.

this was truly hard.....i really like hogwarts and everything but i picked narnia because although i havent watched the movie yet i have read all the books and they are not better than harry potter but htey are brilliant....and narnia is a wonderful place to be in....i would just love it....hogwarts can be more dangerous at times....

I'd go into any of them at any time! Hogwarts is so magical and fun. Narnia is also magical and mysterious. I don't know about Middle Earth, though it sounds good. My first choice would just be Hogwarts over Narnia.

It has to be Middle Earth for me. Especially if I could see Gondolin.





One question gog_sirius. Have you ever read the books or seen the movies? Because if you give LOTR a chance then you will be amazed by it. There are Elves, dwarves, dragons, werewolves and Maiar, and there are battles which are truly amazing.

This really is a tough choice! I picked jumping into any of them at any time! I love the fact that in both MiddleEarth and Narnia, you don't have to be a "magical creature" to enjoy the surroundings. Hogwart's is great, but you have to be a wizard or witch to go there and enjoy it. I'd be one of those with no magical ability whatsoever! If I were garaunteed the ability to do magic, I'd be there in a heartbeat, though! As it stands after all of the appendices in LOTR, it'd be a little depressing, I guess. Everyone's leaving! The hobbits would be nice to hang out with . . .but the elves are leaving, the dwarves are recessing again. . . and such. I'll be more willing to travel to Hogwarts once Voldemort is gone. I like safety. Narnia is great, as well, but you never know how to get back. And once you get to a certian age, you can't return. What's up with that? So much for once a king and queen of narnia, always. . .ah well. So, I'll just pop between them all and be happy!

wow...this is a hard one, but i would have to go with Hogwarts, then Narnia and then middle earth...only because i would be scared to go into middle earth and get stuck in the wars..but oooh, for legalus and that king guy i think i would risk it anyways hehe
no, but seriously, i think that magic is so cool, i would rather be able to do magic than fight creepy orcs or find a secret land..even though i read all of the chronicles of narnia and i also read the lord of the rings books...i know, i know...i read a lot

but still...YAY HOGWARTS!!!!!!1

Cheers
lilred

For me Hogwarts is the whole fantasy world.Hogwarts is the very very good Magical school.It has good teachers which teach very well and it also has a wonder ful thing,i.e.,Quidditch Match which i have never seen before.

Hogwarts and Narnia are tied with me. I just couldn't choose. They're both soo amazing. And Middle Earth comes close behind. I'm just a **** for creativeness, and they all three have enough of it to be in themselves just as amazing as the next. They're all equally fun to think about going into their world.

if i had to pick one of these to go i would go to all three!!!! it would be really cool though if all of them combined to one big one.

No contest for me. Hogwarts is fun, but I've been an Elf living in Middle Earth since the First Age, or at least the early to mid-60s, and wouldn't change my location for anything or anyone!

Hogwarts, but I admit that Narnia seems cool too!

MOD EDIT : Please re-read the forums rules. Short posts are not allowed on the boards.

I picked other! because I dont even know what middle earth is so... But I would pick 'step in to anyone' as in Narnia, and Hogwarts. Although I would really like to go to Hogwarts!

I voted Narnia.... It's much bigger than Hogwarts, but this is assuming you just mean Hogwarts, not the rest of the wizarding world. Narnia is much bigger, and there are lots of creatures there, when Hogwarts isn't so diverse. And the way you get to Narnia is just so awesome! Imagine walking into the closet and finding a whole other world. That would be so cool, it doesn't even translate to words.

I would love to go to Hogwarts( if it excisted of course!) because it would totally rock to learn how use magic. Also it would be awesome because of all of the excting things that happen there, such as the Tri-Wizard Tournument and all of the other stuff. It would also be fun to fight people using magic, or dueling.