of Harry and possessive of Hermione. I do however believe Ron will make it up with him in light of Voldemort. But Harry and Ron will fight first. what do you shippers think?
Full Version: H/R/Hr Love Triangle
I believe that there is a love triangle. Hermione loves Harry, gave up on him and thought she loved Ron. However in Book 7 I think she will realise she loves Harry. Ron loves Hermione and Harry finally realises he does too. i believe there will be a temporary fallout as Ron has always been jealous of Harry and possessive of Hermione. I do however believe Ron will make it up with him in light of Voldemort. But Harry and Ron will fight first. what do you shippers think?
of Harry and possessive of Hermione. I do however believe Ron will make it up with him in light of Voldemort. But Harry and Ron will fight first. what do you shippers think?
there is a great possibility for this and i agree that it would be rons style to get jealous of everyone! 
it would be fun to have a ship like this....quite surprised no one thought of it before 
....
maybe they'll be fighting over whos going to dance with hermione in bill's wedding (if there is a dance)
it would be fun to have a ship like this....quite surprised no one thought of it before ....maybe they'll be fighting over whos going to dance with hermione in bill's wedding (if there is a dance)
I think this is a definite possibility for the seventh book, and I would love to see it! The hints are there and it would add a complex new dynamic to the trio's relationship.
Also, I think it would help to pacify many fans of both sides of the r/hr vs. h/hr debate because it would show that there were indeed romantic aspects to BOTH relationships, even if one of the pairings "wins out" in the end. Fans have been so committed to each of these ships that to have just one or the other sail without a fight will seriously disappoint a lot of fans. A love triangle would legitimize both ships and would be really exciting to read!
(Plus, how cool would it be to see two boys fighting over the brainy girl, for a change? )
Also, I think it would help to pacify many fans of both sides of the r/hr vs. h/hr debate because it would show that there were indeed romantic aspects to BOTH relationships, even if one of the pairings "wins out" in the end. Fans have been so committed to each of these ships that to have just one or the other sail without a fight will seriously disappoint a lot of fans. A love triangle would legitimize both ships and would be really exciting to read!
(Plus, how cool would it be to see two boys fighting over the brainy girl, for a change?
)
I wouldn't mind reading about a love triangle between our Trio in the final book. However, in all honesty, I believe that Hermione has always loved Harry. Harry will realize in the last book that he loves her too. Ron, as someone has already pointed out, has always been jealous of Harry and a bit possessive of Hermione. I believe Ron assumes that Hermione is his to begin with. He isn't going to like Harry trespassing on his turf. Thus, the triangle angle! 
(Grins slyly and laughs)
YES!!!
It's perfect! Well, maybe not to the extreme (we don't want Harry and Ron actually killing each other - figuratively works), but it would be terribly interesting to see how it would play out in book seven. And I agree with Elizabeth Bennett: both sides of the arguement would be brought to light and the outcome would be clear once and for all. All in all, it would make for capitivating reading, if nothing else.
Oh, the possibilities are endless...
YES!!!
It's perfect! Well, maybe not to the extreme (we don't want Harry and Ron actually killing each other - figuratively works), but it would be terribly interesting to see how it would play out in book seven. And I agree with Elizabeth Bennett: both sides of the arguement would be brought to light and the outcome would be clear once and for all. All in all, it would make for capitivating reading, if nothing else.Oh, the possibilities are endless...
I think this is a good idea, but I do not think that it would work. Harry loves Ginny, and if Harry loved hermione to the end of time, wouldn't he leave her behind so she will not get killed to? I think you had a brilliant thought, just you had to sink a little deeper. Srry if you do not like what I had to say,
Lachy
Lachy
Hm, I like the idea of the triangle (mainly because I think that Harry and Hermione would make the best long-term couple, but Ron and Hermione are actually romantically attracted to each other...)
The only thing is... Hermione really flew off her handle when Ron was with Lavendar, but she seemed okay when Harry was with Cho and Ginny. Why the discrepancy? I suppose you can say that it's because Hermione truly loves Harry, so she's happy ss long as he's happy, whereas she is only lustful after Ron, which is why she's unhappy as long as he lusts after someone else...
Peace,
Prof McG
The only thing is... Hermione really flew off her handle when Ron was with Lavendar, but she seemed okay when Harry was with Cho and Ginny. Why the discrepancy? I suppose you can say that it's because Hermione truly loves Harry, so she's happy ss long as he's happy, whereas she is only lustful after Ron, which is why she's unhappy as long as he lusts after someone else...
Peace,
Prof McG
Lachlan, it was clever of you to think like that and its true that if he loved her than he would leave behind but then how come he didn’t refuse it when hermione and ron said they will come and undertake the journey with him. If he loved her he would have made an excuse but maybe this ship will happen throughout the journey!
Its true ron and hermione are attached to each other McGonagallLuvsDumbledore, but there is always the possibility that they will not get together
Its true ron and hermione are attached to each other McGonagallLuvsDumbledore, but there is always the possibility that they will not get together
| QUOTE (*dementor* @ Dec 29 2005, 06:12 AM) |
| Lachlan, it was clever of you to think like that and its true that if he loved her than he would leave behind but then how come he didn’t refuse it when hermione and ron said they will come and undertake the journey with him. If he loved her he would have made an excuse but maybe this ship will happen throughout the journey! Its true ron and hermione are attached to each other McGonagallLuvsDumbledore, but there is always the possibility that they will not get together |
My sentiments exactly.
We have to remember that JKR is writing these books and she wants book 7 to have the Trio together. She wouldn't dream of leaving behind 1/3 of the Trio (Hermione) for the same noble reason, Harry gave Ginny in HBP. Besides, I agree with you *dementor* - that H/Hr will happen in the final book. A love triangle? Perhaps, but not likely. I STILL believe that Ron and Hermione will come to the realization that they care about one another JUST as friends. This will occur in book 7 too, while H/Hr is gradually happening. Just my two cents. But, I think it's a viable storyline.
Hai,
I don't think Ron and Harry will fight in book 7. There are plenty of scenes in all the 6 books explaining their sincere friendship. I like Ron's character very much. Such a cute boy! He will never fight with Harry. I think Ron will know about Hermione's secret love for Harry from Krum. He will make his two best friends to understand each other.
I don't think Ron and Harry will fight in book 7. There are plenty of scenes in all the 6 books explaining their sincere friendship. I like Ron's character very much. Such a cute boy! He will never fight with Harry. I think Ron will know about Hermione's secret love for Harry from Krum. He will make his two best friends to understand each other.
I hardly believe this could ever happen 
Harry didn't show any sign of love toward her, which is just a great friend and the one who help him get out of trouble
Hermione and Ron are clearly jealous of each other, so I'm quite sure (and I really hope so, too
) that in the 7th book this love will finally blossom.
Plus, Harry has different tastes than Ron, isn't he?
In the end...no fight, no, I don't really think ^^
I mean, Madama Rowling has showed us her cynical side many times (killing the ones more important to poor Harry), but...a fight for love...seem a little bit naive and childish, and I think in the last book there'll be many more important things to fight for
Harry didn't show any sign of love toward her, which is just a great friend and the one who help him get out of trouble
Hermione and Ron are clearly jealous of each other, so I'm quite sure (and I really hope so, too
) that in the 7th book this love will finally blossom.Plus, Harry has different tastes than Ron, isn't he?
In the end...no fight, no, I don't really think ^^
I mean, Madama Rowling has showed us her cynical side many times (killing the ones more important to poor Harry), but...a fight for love...seem a little bit naive and childish, and I think in the last book there'll be many more important things to fight for
i know im not a moderator but id just like to remind anyone against this ship that ships are for supporters so dont post if your against it.
anyway everyone has their opinions
back to the subject...
even if harry doesnt show any sign of love it may happen suddenly, afterall before the HBP did we know that ron would go out with Lavender. there are so many chances of this ship happening and let me say my version of what i think :
sorry i just deleted all my post
because it would be too long. i'll make my first fanfic out of it instead
i'll just put things shortly. ron likes hermione but krum sees them together and gets reaaally sad so hermione stops speaking to ron all of a sudden and he doesnt know why but harry knows and tries to solve thigns but hten he starts liking hermione too and so they would be fighting over hermione:D
hehe
anyway everyone has their opinions
back to the subject...
even if harry doesnt show any sign of love it may happen suddenly, afterall before the HBP did we know that ron would go out with Lavender. there are so many chances of this ship happening and let me say my version of what i think
:sorry i just deleted all my post
because it would be too long. i'll make my first fanfic out of it instead i'll just put things shortly. ron likes hermione but krum sees them together and gets reaaally sad so hermione stops speaking to ron all of a sudden and he doesnt know why but harry knows and tries to solve thigns but hten he starts liking hermione too and so they would be fighting over hermione:D
hehe
i didn't see the "only supporters" advice...in that case I shouldn't have posted anything..
morwen, i didnt mean no offence i was just reminding everyone in general so please dont get offended! 
well back to the ship! very interesting topic and many possibilities so whoever is supporting it keep your fingers crossed. someimes i find it hard to support so many ships, like R/Hr and H/Hr and H/G .....and so many when each one is against but most ships around have a chance so whoever supports the ship they like just keep your figners crossed!
it would be sweet seeing everyone fighting over hermione and not *the chosen one* for once
well back to the ship! very interesting topic and many possibilities so whoever is supporting it keep your fingers crossed. someimes i find it hard to support so many ships, like R/Hr and H/Hr and H/G .....and so many when each one is against but most ships around have a chance so whoever supports the ship they like just keep your figners crossed!
it would be sweet seeing everyone fighting over hermione and not *the chosen one* for once
I thought "future love triangle" from the very first book and believed it would happen in the last book after reading the second one. The bottom line: the trio itself is my favorite character, and not any one of them separately. The potential angst and growth experience a story line like this can provide is great, plus a sad or bittersweet resolution at the end. After reading HBP, I began to seek out trio fics as a reminder as to how well they work together--unfortunately the vast majority are not intended for those under 18.
Just to clarify things here. It has been stated here that all ships thread are for supporters ONLY regardless it was stated at the title or not. So, to put it simply, unless you support this H/R/Hr love triangle, don't post.
Thanks.
Thanks.
As a Harmonian, I believe, were my ship to sail, that a clash with Ron would be inevitable. Ron has proven the power and stubbornness of his jealousy time and again. Since the conflict would be centered around Hermione, the one who usually mediates between them during these times, it would be their greatest clash ever and a true test to their friendship. To tell the truth, the only way I can see either H/H or R/H occurring without damaging their friendship and upsetting shippers is for either Ron or Harry to die in battle.
However, given the potential of this conflict utterly destroying the trio, does anyone here think it possible that J.K. Rowling may be doing away with all ships involving them? Think about it. As several have pointed out, there is neither Harry/Ginny (broke up) or Ron/Hermione (no concrete confessions) at the end of HBP. They have more important things to worry with at the moment, and they’ll need to trust each other completely to survive. Also, the way she handled ships in HBP could be her subtle way of telling us how “silly” our shipping wars have been.
Personally, as much as I would LOVE to see Harry/Hermione, I hope Mrs. Rowling concentrates more on the adventure/quest aspect and saves the shipping until after the final confrontation. The story itself has become too important. Ships would be more of a distraction at this point.
However, given the potential of this conflict utterly destroying the trio, does anyone here think it possible that J.K. Rowling may be doing away with all ships involving them? Think about it. As several have pointed out, there is neither Harry/Ginny (broke up) or Ron/Hermione (no concrete confessions) at the end of HBP. They have more important things to worry with at the moment, and they’ll need to trust each other completely to survive. Also, the way she handled ships in HBP could be her subtle way of telling us how “silly” our shipping wars have been.
Personally, as much as I would LOVE to see Harry/Hermione, I hope Mrs. Rowling concentrates more on the adventure/quest aspect and saves the shipping until after the final confrontation. The story itself has become too important. Ships would be more of a distraction at this point.
yes its right that ships might be of a distraction to the story and according to what you said TerranOverMind that either Ron or Harry will die, maybe ron dies but i dont think Harry will before his last challenge with Voldemort! and Harry would not break up with Hermione and Ron if they get together because he knows how much they like each other even if they dont get together.
it is therefore most unlikely for Harry to die before he meets his challenge with Voldemort which will be after any ship has taken place because Jo always leaves the challenges with Voldemort in the last few chapters..so i dont think many ships will occur after it and even if its after the challenge, people will be too busy celebrating or mourning the death of Voldemort or Harry, whichever dies.( i think that Harry will lose his powers or something like that or maybe they both die or both lose powers! )
well back to this ship its definitely not going to happen before they leave for he journey and i have a question concerning it...if Hermione really loved Harry why would she beam when Harry went out with Cho or Ginny but maybeat that time she didnt love him ....but confusing :S
it is therefore most unlikely for Harry to die before he meets his challenge with Voldemort which will be after any ship has taken place because Jo always leaves the challenges with Voldemort in the last few chapters..so i dont think many ships will occur after it and even if its after the challenge, people will be too busy celebrating or mourning the death of Voldemort or Harry, whichever dies.( i think that Harry will lose his powers or something like that or maybe they both die or both lose powers! )
well back to this ship its definitely not going to happen before they leave for he journey and i have a question concerning it...if Hermione really loved Harry why would she beam when Harry went out with Cho or Ginny but maybeat that time she didnt love him
....but confusing :S
I just wanted to clear a few things up for *dementor.*
according to what you said, that either Ron or Harry will die, maybe ron dies but i dont think Harry will before his last challenge with Voldemort!
I hypothesized that Ron or Harry would have to die “in battle.” The only battle I think Harry would ever die in would be with Voldemort. Ron could die anytime. In fact, it could push Harry to finally use the Avada Kadavra curse on Voldy.
Harry would not break up with Hermione and Ron if they get together
No, he wouldn’t. He is okay with it in general. I only said that if Harry were to express feelings for Hermione, trouble would come from Ron.
his challenge with Voldemort which will be after any ship has taken place
Not necessarily. In fact, many ships could result in the aftermath of the final confrontation, whether in mourning or celebration. As far as the trio, if Harry were to die in the battle with Voldemort, R/H could definitely happen. If Ron dies at any time, Harry and Hermione would most likely need to be there for each other to mourn, and romantic feelings could surface from the trauma. I still think ships shouldn’t be “seriously” covered until the “adventure” is over (small hints would be welcome, though)
All this talk of Harry or Ron dying in the end has made me notice a new possibility. What if Hermione dies in battle? That sure would throw a wrench in the major ships, but it would also be something that could motivate Harry and Ron to new heights and finally end this war.
according to what you said, that either Ron or Harry will die, maybe ron dies but i dont think Harry will before his last challenge with Voldemort!
I hypothesized that Ron or Harry would have to die “in battle.” The only battle I think Harry would ever die in would be with Voldemort. Ron could die anytime. In fact, it could push Harry to finally use the Avada Kadavra curse on Voldy.
Harry would not break up with Hermione and Ron if they get together
No, he wouldn’t. He is okay with it in general. I only said that if Harry were to express feelings for Hermione, trouble would come from Ron.
his challenge with Voldemort which will be after any ship has taken place
Not necessarily. In fact, many ships could result in the aftermath of the final confrontation, whether in mourning or celebration. As far as the trio, if Harry were to die in the battle with Voldemort, R/H could definitely happen. If Ron dies at any time, Harry and Hermione would most likely need to be there for each other to mourn, and romantic feelings could surface from the trauma. I still think ships shouldn’t be “seriously” covered until the “adventure” is over (small hints would be welcome, though)
All this talk of Harry or Ron dying in the end has made me notice a new possibility. What if Hermione dies in battle? That sure would throw a wrench in the major ships, but it would also be something that could motivate Harry and Ron to new heights and finally end this war.
| QUOTE |
| Not necessarily. In fact, many ships could result in the aftermath of the final confrontation, whether in mourning or celebration. As far as the trio, if Harry were to die in the battle with Voldemort, R/H could definitely happen. If Ron dies at any time, Harry and Hermione would most likely need to be there for each other to mourn, and romantic feelings could surface from the trauma. I still think ships shouldn’t be “seriously” covered until the “adventure” is over (small hints would be welcome, though) |
if Harry died then Hermione would be too sad to get together with ron. even though i dont think she has a big crush on him, she would be too busy crying over harry and afterall hes her best friend and like i said Jo always leaves the challenges with Voldemort in the last few chapters so if she does its unlikely that any ship happens after it...
if voldemort dies then maybe they will get together after if they still havent but i'd like to mention something..umm...i thought this ship was about R/Hr/H and i think we are slipping out of the subject!
lol 
ok it looks like i am going to have to say this yet again. JKR is only writing one more book about harry potter. the final edition to the story. *sighs* if harry and ron started fighting over harry it would go of story and it would be about harry potter defeating the dark lord voldemort alongside his best friends it would be harry and ron falling out over a girl and making it a blood bath. JKR is not writing a book the size of an airplane. she is writing probably a few inches of an airplane, so she cannot fit all this in. i think we need to get it into our minds is that this story is not going to go on forever. its going to be finished in a couple of years. forever..
Mr. Pickles,
Just remember that when JKR revealed Tonks/Lupin, she did it in ONE sentence! It was a big surprise! But, effectively written, and much to the delight of the T/L shippers.
The final book doesn't have to be the size of this airplane you talk about. She can easily go into the shipping aspect of the book without much fanfare. But, you have to admit, the shipping MUST be resolved. It's one of those 'loose ends' that has to be tied up! After all, H/G is over and R/Hr still hasn't happened! And, in my mindset, H/Hr still has a chance!
Just remember that when JKR revealed Tonks/Lupin, she did it in ONE sentence! It was a big surprise! But, effectively written, and much to the delight of the T/L shippers.
The final book doesn't have to be the size of this airplane you talk about. She can easily go into the shipping aspect of the book without much fanfare. But, you have to admit, the shipping MUST be resolved. It's one of those 'loose ends' that has to be tied up! After all, H/G is over and R/Hr still hasn't happened! And, in my mindset, H/Hr still has a chance!
lmao Mr Pickles?
yeah but this thread is about harry and ron fighting over hermione. she cant just do that in one sentence and then they are best friends again. yes she has got to do some ships but not ones that have consequences like this one.
yeah but this thread is about harry and ron fighting over hermione. she cant just do that in one sentence and then they are best friends again. yes she has got to do some ships but not ones that have consequences like this one.
i know this is a dum question but what is Imao....dont worry i understand abbreviations but ive been reading this one a couple of times without knowing what it stands for
yea its true Jo wont have space to make all the ships happen but they are all on one journey (the trio) so it wont distract us from many things would it
and James Pickles maybe you pressed add reply 4 times
yea its true Jo wont have space to make all the ships happen but they are all on one journey (the trio) so it wont distract us from many things would it
and James Pickles maybe you pressed add reply 4 times
its Lmao not Imao but never mind. it mean laugh my donkey off.
L M A O
it doesnt really mean donkey but it means the other word for donkey. lol maybe i did press add reply four times. yeah cause i was on my uncles computer then and its a really slow one, so maybe i did.
L M A O
it doesnt really mean donkey but it means the other word for donkey. lol maybe i did press add reply four times. yeah cause i was on my uncles computer then and its a really slow one, so maybe i did.
It's not a problem, I've deleted them. It happens sometimes when you have a slower connection - you think the computer has frozen and your reply hasn't been added, but it has, then every time you click add reply, it adds your post again.
Okay then, if we could get back to the topic please. Thanks.
Okay then, if we could get back to the topic please. Thanks.
| QUOTE |
| if Harry died then Hermione would be too sad to get together with ron. even though i dont think she has a big crush on him, she would be too busy crying over harry and afterall hes her best friend and like i said Jo always leaves the challenges with Voldemort in the last few chapters so if she does its unlikely that any ship happens after it... if voldemort dies then maybe they will get together after if they still havent |
what do you think of that? likely or unlikely?
theres so many people (characters) who would get sad if ron and harry start fighting over hermione but like ive said i would be fun to ee that only i hope they dont break up!
A love triangle would be a great story line and a big possiblility. In the end Hermione will definatly end up with either Ron or Harry. I hope neither of them is left out though at the end and finish being single. At first I was all for the R/Hr but now i think I prefer the idea of H/Hr !
They are so cute together!!!
I dont think Ron and Harry will fight over her but their will be signs of jelousy definatly.
thanks michelle, yeah i was on my uncles computer and it is ancient, so it is very slow and i remember clicking on it about four times so thank you. ok well back on topic if harry died hermione and ron would be deeply upset and yes they would get together because it is plainly obvious that hermione loves ron anyway and JKR said in that interveiw with emerson and melissa that you could plainly tell they loved one another. they would get together if harry lived anyway but maybe hermione and ron would split up if harry died for each others protection.
| QUOTE |
| if harry died hermione and ron would be deeply upset and yes they would get together because it is plainly obvious that hermione loves ron anyway and JKR said in that interveiw with emerson and melissa that you could plainly tell they loved one another. they would get together if harry lived anyway but maybe hermione and ron would split up if harry died for each others protection. |
exactly what i was thinking but the good thing about this hsip is that nobody would be left out except maybe ginn, but we can rule that out seeing as she wont be on the journey with them!
well....on the journey harry and ron lose hermione and she starts crying and realises how much she like them and then when they find her they get together!
anyone has a reply to that?
lol, no ginny probably wont be on the journey. but ive been thinking about writing this fan fiction and it finished when love destroys voldemort. voldemort casts avada kedavra on ginny and harry and they both fly back and land ontop of each other hand in hand. then this pink smokey stuff lifts them up and then hits voldemort and he dies. dont you see. ginny and harrys love saves them and kills voldemorts as they become one. it is unlikely to happen but it could lol. anyway. harry, hermione and ron will fight voldemort together so they cannot possibly be in a love triangle because they would all split up.
hii personally i think harry should go wif ginny & ron wif hermionie *nods* n e 1 agree ? write bk xoxox
*nods* n e 1 agree ? write bk xoxox
i used to be a ron and hermione shipper but now i have changed my mind because of the way both ron and harry no matter what always protect hermione and allthough ron is the most obvious showing that he loves hermione i also believe that harry does aswell but from previeus books harry isnt as open and obvious as ron but i believe that he loves hermione aswell
at the end of book seven u would love to see some sort of arguement between ron and harry over who gets hermione personally i would like to see her get with ron then realise its harry she wants and then hapy ending i think that would be great
this is my personal opinion so please dont send me nasty replies lol
at the end of book seven u would love to see some sort of arguement between ron and harry over who gets hermione personally i would like to see her get with ron then realise its harry she wants and then hapy ending i think that would be great
this is my personal opinion so please dont send me nasty replies lol
I think Hermione loves Ron but he ignores her and she is tired of all the bickering so she makes up with harry. Ron finally realises he shouldn't give up on hermione and he's jealous of Harry. And at last the three of them ends up separate. (that would be sad)
| QUOTE (Thegirlwholived @ Jan 8 2006, 06:46 PM) |
| I think Hermione loves Ron but he ignores her and she is tired of all the bickering so she makes up with harry. Ron finally realises he shouldn't give up on hermione and he's jealous of Harry. And at last the three of them ends up separate. (that would be sad) |
What an interesting thought... None of the trio wind up with someone at the end...Of course, as intriguing as it is, J. K. Rowling would never hear the end of it from her fans... but that makes it all the better!
All in all, I want to see Harry and Ron have a real fight for a change... not just one where they don't speak to each other. Heck, they may even become better friends because of it...
Look at this smilie I found:
(sorry, I know it's off topic, but I couldn't resist...)
haha. i like your smiley. maybe ron and harry might try to kill each other and harry lost his desire to fight voldy.
I think there is a love triangle. ron loves hermonie, hermonie loves harry and harry doesnt like anyone but he is rons best friend which finishs the triangle. i think hermonie will relize she loves ron and they will get togeether. i dont know who harry will end up with.... hes alreddi went out with ginny so i just dont know. well thaz what i think
and maybe they'll get into a first fight that would be good. the only fight i have seen at hogwarts is between fred and george of move 4. t would be good. i mean if hermonie can scare off malfoy i bet th could do better.
i love you smilie
i love you smilie
I think there won't be a love triangle since Harry Potter isn't about love. And Harry has more important things to worry about than [MOD EDITED] some girl. [MOD EDITED]
And Harry has more important things to worry about than [MOD EDITED] some girl. [MOD EDITED]
How do you know if Hermione has ever loved Harry?
I can't see in the books anywhere that tells Hermione loves Harry
I can't see in the books anywhere that tells Hermione loves Harry
There isn't a love triangle cuase Harry/Hermione doean't like each other. I agree with zviper. It's Hermione and Ron all the way, and Harry and Ginny. Although Harry and Ginny might happen later, cause Harry has to destroy Voldemort first.
Horsewang, remember that the only thing preventing voldemort from killing harry was love so thats really important in the book.
seeing as harry seems firm with the decision he made about ginny it means he will only go back to her when he defeats voldemort. in that case a triangle thing is reallly likely seeing as they will be older and more understanding and more serious and i think theres a great posssibility of it happening!
seeing as harry seems firm with the decision he made about ginny it means he will only go back to her when he defeats voldemort. in that case a triangle thing is reallly likely seeing as they will be older and more understanding and more serious and i think theres a great posssibility of it happening!
| QUOTE |
| There isn't a love triangle cuase Harry/Hermione doean't like each other. I agree with zviper. It's Hermione and Ron all the way, and Harry and Ginny. |
Excuse me, and who made you Queen? I'm sorry, but this is a love triangle thread, and if you don't support that theory, I suggest you don't state your beliefs on other ships, seeing as some shippers (such as I) will not agree with you, and I do not fancy someone telling me what ship will and will not sail. Sorry, I had to say it.. Sorry MODS *hides* xP
Anyways, my feeling regarding to the thread: There could definatly be a love triangle betwenn the three. Maybe not the extenct that Harry and Ron will never speak to each other again (lets' hope not anyway) but there definatly could be possibilities. If it did turn out that Harry liked Hermione he would probably be in denial, and then if all else failed, he would probably not do anything because he knows that Ron likes Hermione. Kind of unfair don't you think? Harry isn't allowed to like someone because someone else allready 'took' them? In my opinion she isn't taken yet, and is free bait.
As much as I don't like to use Hermione as 'bait' and wait to see who catches her, because I believe that is really low, If Harry did like Hermione I would really like to see his reaction, and Ron's for that matter. The last book (Ships wise) would become totally unpredictable, which I would absolutly love to see the outcome of. Hey, I like surprises
-Dominique
Dominique, you rock girl
I think the idea of this love triangle is terribly intriguing and I could definetly see it happening. Wouldn't it be interesting if Ron killed Harry in the end? That'd be a shocker! Just kidding though, I know JKR wouldn't do that to us!! Anyways, of course I hope Hermione and Harry do hook up at the end but you really never know. If it's not with Harry, I hope it's with someone besides Ron because even though we would never truly know, I highly doubt Ron and Hermy would last. I can see it now... 25 year old Hermione with a messy house, 4 red-haired children running around like maniac's and Ron laying around all day shouting orders I don't want our Hermy to end up like that
I think the idea of this love triangle is terribly intriguing and I could definetly see it happening. Wouldn't it be interesting if Ron killed Harry in the end? That'd be a shocker! Just kidding though, I know JKR wouldn't do that to us!! Anyways, of course I hope Hermione and Harry do hook up at the end but you really never know. If it's not with Harry, I hope it's with someone besides Ron because even though we would never truly know, I highly doubt Ron and Hermy would last. I can see it now... 25 year old Hermione with a messy house, 4 red-haired children running around like maniac's and Ron laying around all day shouting orders
I don't want our Hermy to end up like that
to all non-supporters...if you have read all this thread then you must have seen this by a mod:
| QUOTE |
| Just to clarify things here. It has been stated here that all ships thread are for supporters ONLY regardless it was stated at the title or not. So, to put it simply, unless you support this H/R/Hr love triangle, don't post. Thanks. |
by zyra123
well back to the topic:
lol....no way would ron kill harry just for hermione.....i'd kill ron first...
sorry i dont think that makes sense...but the point is theres a great possibility of it happening seeing as they'll be the trio in the journey and maybe something extroadinary will happen like one of them getting lost or something like that and so they suddenly realise they cant lose anyone....well i hope you know what im trying to say
Hai,
There is a big chance for a love triangle. But Ron and Harry fighting over Hermione, I don't like that idea at all. From the beginning it is very much clear that Hermione likes Harry more than a friend. There are many scenes confirmed that Harry thought that Ron and Hermione are liking each other. For examble in GOF Chapter 19, page no 279,
"What about Ron, though?" he said. "Don't you want to go with him?"
"Oh... well..." Hermione went slightly pink. "I thought we might meet up with him in the Three Broomsticks..."
But in the Three Broomsticks though Ron was there Hermione did not meet him. She was with Harry.
Like these there are many incidents which made Harry to think that Hermione and Ron are liking each other. So he did not want to risk his friendship with Ron. But if Ron realised that Hermione is liking Harry then he will not fight over her, sure. Ron is such a lovable character. But if Ron doesn't have any feeling for Hermione more than a best friend what will happen?
Another interesting moment on GOF chapter 22 page no 339,
Harry didn't answer. He knew perfectly well whom he'd like to ask, but working up the nerves was something else.... Cho was a year older than he was; she was very pretty;
I think Harry wanted to ask Hermione but he didn't have the courage because he thought Hermione and Ron are liking each other. In fact he get shocked when he came to know that Ron did't ask her for the ball and it was Neville.
I think these dots (......) play a significant role in the story. JKR used them in many places just to confuse us.
There is a big chance for a love triangle. But Ron and Harry fighting over Hermione, I don't like that idea at all. From the beginning it is very much clear that Hermione likes Harry more than a friend. There are many scenes confirmed that Harry thought that Ron and Hermione are liking each other. For examble in GOF Chapter 19, page no 279,
"What about Ron, though?" he said. "Don't you want to go with him?"
"Oh... well..." Hermione went slightly pink. "I thought we might meet up with him in the Three Broomsticks..."
But in the Three Broomsticks though Ron was there Hermione did not meet him. She was with Harry.
Like these there are many incidents which made Harry to think that Hermione and Ron are liking each other. So he did not want to risk his friendship with Ron. But if Ron realised that Hermione is liking Harry then he will not fight over her, sure. Ron is such a lovable character. But if Ron doesn't have any feeling for Hermione more than a best friend what will happen?
Another interesting moment on GOF chapter 22 page no 339,
Harry didn't answer. He knew perfectly well whom he'd like to ask, but working up the nerves was something else.... Cho was a year older than he was; she was very pretty;
I think Harry wanted to ask Hermione but he didn't have the courage because he thought Hermione and Ron are liking each other. In fact he get shocked when he came to know that Ron did't ask her for the ball and it was Neville.
I think these dots (......) play a significant role in the story. JKR used them in many places just to confuse us.
Hi Lupin123
Please review the forums rules here, in particular the part in regards to signatures. I'm afraid I'm going to have to ask you to edit your siggie as you are only allowed no more than FIVE lines of text.
Please feel free to send one of us moderators a PM (Private Message) if you have any further questions. Cheers.
Please review the forums rules here, in particular the part in regards to signatures. I'm afraid I'm going to have to ask you to edit your siggie as you are only allowed no more than FIVE lines of text.
Please feel free to send one of us moderators a PM (Private Message) if you have any further questions. Cheers.
Hai,
I am sorry and I don't know about that rule. I will edit my signature. Once again sorry.
I am sorry and I don't know about that rule. I will edit my signature. Once again sorry.
| QUOTE |
| But Ron and Harry fighting over Hermione, I don't like that idea at all. From the beginning it is very much clear that Hermione likes Harry more than a friend. There are many scenes confirmed that Harry thought that Ron and Hermione are liking each other. |
Well… I think Ron is very cool and everything but I get the feeling that he gets jealous quite often. For one thing, he’s always been jealous of Harry’s money and fame. And for another in HBP page 270 chapter Felix Felicis, when Ron asked Harry if hermione had really snogged Krum, Harry doesn’t answer but then it says:
“However, Ron seemed to gather the worst from the look on Harry’s face.
‘Dilligrout,’ he said darkly to the fat lady, and they climbed through the portrait hole into the common room.”
Now i am not mentioning all the parts obviously and this one might not seem clear but why would Ron care whatever Hermione did? It was a sign of anger and the same goes towards hermione who said in HBP page 283 hermione is talking to Harry in an classroom when Ron walks in and then Hermione sends a flock of birds at him…well after this is what happened:
“ ‘ Gerremoffme!’ he yelled, but with one last look of vindictive fury, Hermione wrenched open the door and disappeared through it. Harry thought he heard a sob before it slammed”.Again, why would Hermione care whatever Ron did if she had done something similar? This is a sign of jealousy and if i am not mistaken, in HBP in the beginning of one chapter (after this chapter) it talks about Ron’s jealousy and I cant find the page now but I caught a glimpse of it a second ago..
Now there are many parts, which show Ron/Hermione but never Harry with hermione. Well Harry comes in, in the 7th book. Ron and hermione would be too busy helping Harry, than going out but if all three are working together in their hardest yet adventure from all that they’ve had in the past, than maybe they will find that all three like each other. Now many people think differently and think that there are great signs of Harry and hermione and they may be right of course because Harry never fights with Hermione and maybe JKR was trying to confuse us throughout the years.
Anyway if either Ron or Harry get together it would be much better for all that a triangle thing happens because nobody will be left out.
That’s all for now…i have been typing too much, possibly the longest post i have ever made!
Hai Dementor,
I don't think Ron is jealous of Harry's money and fame. But definately he has a complex because of his poverty. Both Harry and Hermione aware of it and they don't mistake him for that matter. Like you said the three of them like each other very much and that is the beautiful point of the story.
I agree with you that Ron is angry towards Hermione because he thought she snogged with Krum. He thought snogging with Krum is sort of fraternising with the enemy, as he told at the time of yule ball.
Talking about the birds attacking scene, I don't think Hermione is angry towards Ron because of that Lavender matter. I think she is angry with Harry because he fooled her by making her to believe that he had given lucky potion to Ron. In that scene the conversation is not full between herself and Harry. They interupted by Ron so she irritated and attacked him. After making this thing (lucky potion) clear with Harry in the library then they started to talk with each other as normal . In fact Harry is very much happy about their compromise.
JKR will give answers to all those questions in the next book, I hope and can't wait to read.
I don't think Ron is jealous of Harry's money and fame. But definately he has a complex because of his poverty. Both Harry and Hermione aware of it and they don't mistake him for that matter. Like you said the three of them like each other very much and that is the beautiful point of the story.
I agree with you that Ron is angry towards Hermione because he thought she snogged with Krum. He thought snogging with Krum is sort of fraternising with the enemy, as he told at the time of yule ball.
Talking about the birds attacking scene, I don't think Hermione is angry towards Ron because of that Lavender matter. I think she is angry with Harry because he fooled her by making her to believe that he had given lucky potion to Ron. In that scene the conversation is not full between herself and Harry. They interupted by Ron so she irritated and attacked him. After making this thing (lucky potion) clear with Harry in the library then they started to talk with each other as normal . In fact Harry is very much happy about their compromise.
JKR will give answers to all those questions in the next book, I hope and can't wait to read.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.