Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Dumbledore Sacrifices Self For Harry Like Lily Did
Veritaserum Forums > Books > The Half-Blood Prince
Pages: 1, 2
Ladie Lily Potter
I don't think there will be protection because they're not related like Lily and Harry were. But it's a good idea. But then ... even if there were protection, just like Lily's protection it will wear off by his birthday.
padfootx3
QUOTE(Neville Loves Me @ Jun 13 2007, 09:48 AM) [snapback]398340[/snapback]

consider this: perhaps Dumbledore sacrificed himself for Draco. If Draco has the love-protection that Harry had from Lily, perhaps we will see some good come out of Dumbledore's sacrifice/Draco. This is for those who believe Harry and Draco will unite for the destruction of Voldemort.

*Neville Loves Me*



I think that is an excellent theory. I don't think that Draco would have received the love protection like that of harry, but i think that he was trying to protect Draco.
harry_potter_luvr_4life
I think that after much consideration Dumbledore did sacrifice himself for Harry. If I were Dumbledore I would have done the same thing. Freezing Harry, making him watch him die. It all makes since now that I think about it.

wub.gif LONG LIVE HARRY POTTER!!!!! wub.gif
babydoll
Well, I know it's pointless me answering this now after the 7th book is out but I just wanted to point something out. Lily did literally die for Harry, as in she died IN PLACE of Harry. Voldemort intended to kill Harry and Lily took the killing curse instead of Harry. This is not the case with Dumbledore, he stunned Harry to stop him from interfering but in the situation where Dumbledore died Draco Malfoy, the death eaters, Snape and whoever else was there willing to kill Dumbledore were there with the intention to kill Dumbledore, not Harry (in this particular moment). I'm not saying they wouldn't have killed Harry too had they known he was there but the intention in that moment was to find and kill Dumbledore so while he protected him by stopping him from interfering and putting himself in danger he did not, as Lily did, die for Harry.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.