Hermione to kiss Krum in GOF
posted by: Matthew, on 01-15-05 @ 9:12 PM

Emma Watson was recently interviewed by the Dutch magazine "Joepie," and E-W.net has posted a translation.

Who would you like to kiss in a scene?
Emma: Brad Pitt! I love him! Too bad he's too old to play a wizard student. In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, I need to kiss one Viktor Krum. That part would be perfect for Brad Pitt if you ask me. I've met the person who's gonna be Viktor and he seems okay.


Note: It's possible that Emma is merely speculating, because her character never kisses Krum in the book, but David Heyman did say that hormones are raging in this one.

Also, she said this about Dan and Rupert: "Thank God I'm a girl, I think Dan spares me from his pranks sometimes because of that. Most of the time Rupert is the victim. Those two are unbelievable. It wouldn't surprise me if Rupert and Dan form a comic duo!"


WARNING

The comments below may contain spoilers pertaining to
"Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince"

Read at your own risk

Comments (183)

Every time I post a comment it get's deleted...Anyway, I think this interview is not exactly correct. Hermione doesn't kiss Krum. If the interview was "recently" then she would not be allowed to spill the beans about her apparently kissing Krum & I think she would have more to say then, "I've met the person who's gonna be Viktor and he seems okay". She obviously wouldn't have just MET him if they're already 75% done filming the movie.
post by Kristy on 01-15-05 @ 9:19 PM

No way!! They can't stray from the books that much. Hermione's first kiss will be with Ron, both in the books and the movies...or else jk lol
post by Linda on 01-15-05 @ 9:23 PM

lol...yeah I know. I'd be so upset if they did that in the movie! I mean, wouldn't JKR save Hermione's first kiss for the 6th book? The interview also says that she holds hands and hugs Ron in the movie. Uhmmm hello!? They're fighting the whole time! That's impossible! This interview is definately not accurate.
post by Kristy on 01-15-05 @ 9:27 PM

Interesting but you guys have to understand, just because Hermione didn't kiss Krum in the book doesn't mean she can't in the film. Whenever a book is adapted into a film changes are made to the story or to the way it's told and there's nothing anyone but the filmmakers can do about it.
post by Doreen on 01-15-05 @ 9:28 PM

Kristy-
I think that was a typo, and it should have said the 3rd film at the part about the R/Hr hug. Because they did have a hug scene in that and that did get cut.

But rock on, Hermione! You kiss that Bulgarian!
post by Jake on 01-15-05 @ 9:29 PM

What I can't understand is the part about WB thinking that the actors are too old to continue doing the movies after GoF? Hasn't that been discussed to death already? Aren't we all just waiting for the news about them getting contracted for OotP, well that's what I've heard?
post by Marianne on 01-15-05 @ 9:30 PM

Jake--> Yes, it is a typo. The whole article. Because if the interviewer is asking about the fourth movie, why would Rupert and Emma be saying something that happened in the 3rd?
post by Kristy on 01-15-05 @ 9:32 PM

I don't think that this is an accurate article. Hermione may kiss Krum in the movies, but they talked about the hand-holding moment and the hug scene that we knew got cut to be in the fourth film btw. ron and hermione. And also, i don't think that a clip from a magazine like this would be the first to say that they aren't continuing their roles...which still hasn't been decided yet! I hope they stay, but as for this article, i don't think that it is very true.
post by CM on 01-15-05 @ 9:47 PM

But Hermione already kissed ron (and harry) in GoF and OotP... come on ppl uve read the books..
post by D_S on 01-15-05 @ 9:48 PM

We mean a kiss on the mouth!!!
post by Linda on 01-15-05 @ 9:54 PM

I think this is a wrong translations, I know e-w.net has the mag, Veritaserum people can you do your own homework and translate what it says on the scane thanks.
post by tam on 01-15-05 @ 10:01 PM

and if it is a kiss is going to be a kiss on his cheek maybe a good bye kiss..
post by wwo on 01-15-05 @ 10:02 PM

Ohh... sorry Linda... GEESH!!....lol
post by D_S on 01-15-05 @ 10:06 PM

if JKR wants hermiones first kiss to be in the 6th book then she most likely wont let her kiss krum in the movie or it would just mess everything up
post by kaitlyn on 01-15-05 @ 10:13 PM

The Rupert part is wrong, it says that they hold hand and so on, but that it was taking out of the 4th movie, hello the 4th movie hasn't came out yet and they haven't even done any final editing on this movie.
I think the info in this article is wrong, not the translation the the person who wrote this this article mix old interviews with current ones..
post by wow on 01-15-05 @ 10:14 PM

How old is Emma? 14? She probably just means a kiss on the cheek as opposed to well, um, the other kind ;P And I doubt that they would put it in the movie if it wasn't in the book or crucial to the story because GoF is already so long and they have tons of stuff to get through. Oh and Hermione is only allowed to kiss Ron! Lol.
post by Wonky Faint on 01-15-05 @ 10:23 PM

...or Harry! :P There's more then R/Hr shippers alive out there! lol. Don't worry, I'm not an insane one.
post by Kristy on 01-15-05 @ 10:31 PM

I could say I'm insane with R/Hr... It is impossible for JK Rowling to ever approve of Hermione kissing Krum before she kisses Ron... It's so wrong! If jk rowling approved of that, it would be really disappointing... I mean how much of the book can the flim makers screw around with?
post by Amanda on 01-15-05 @ 10:55 PM

maybe is not going to be ron or harry but Vicktor after all, imagine that!..
post by nop on 01-15-05 @ 11:20 PM

(referring to what nop said) NOO!!! I am a fervent Harry/Hermione shipper, but even Ron/Hermione's better than "Vicky"/Hermione! And personally, I believe the article's maybe even a fake...I mean, I seem to remember some "interview" with Daniel Radcliffe that popped up sometime before PoA was released where he said he wasn't doing GoF or something of the sort. Later, it turns out they never did such an interview. And also, I agree with the people before me that according to Jamie Waylett they're not even supposed to say who's playing the Weird Sisters music. Would the actors really be allowed to give away stuff like a kiss that doesn't happen in the book?
post by yellowjacket on 01-15-05 @ 11:33 PM

I think we sholdn't make a big deal out of this, this is a foreing article, and it looks like they have extract many quotes from here and there, notice how Rupert's comments are not correct for this movie, there he was talking about the 3rd movie not this one.
SO I won't even bother to take this article seriously...
post by nop on 01-15-05 @ 11:49 PM

I'm sure that the girl who translated this tried her best, and for all we know it MIGHT be legit, but when translating things, people have to be very careful - even the slightest tense mistake can change the whole meaning of something. Besides, wouldn't it make much more sense if it was a British magazine or an American magazine that did this interview? How in the hell would a Dutch interviewer be able to snag one with Emma, let alone right in the middle of filming GOF? No offence to anyone who is of the background, but I mean think logically here ...
post by Jessi on 01-15-05 @ 11:59 PM

what? I think this Article May be WRONG enough!!!
i'm agree with yellow jacket... even i am a H/HR shipper , Ron/Hermione's better than "Vicky"/Hermione!
post by Emy on 01-16-05 @ 12:35 AM

Hmm, interesting... it's very hard to tell if this article really is correct or not. It is a translation, so there could be a mistake... then again, movies are often different than the books... i'm so undecided! All i know now is that i REALLY can't wait until the movie comes out!
post by crissieo on 01-16-05 @ 12:52 AM

NO WAY! Emm aint kissin no1. I have seen a video interview in which she was asked if she wud kiss in the future movies. She said "NO WAY"
post by Grawp on 01-16-05 @ 1:40 AM

yes, brad pitt is too old for you and you are a chit of a girl for brad pitt.

and yes, the person who's gonna be Viktor is just 'okay' for you coz you are too smug
to other HP newcomers who haven't in any films before, like you in the first film.

is it just me or is emma watson too arrogant?
post by ally on 01-16-05 @ 2:14 AM

Oh! If Hermione will kiss that Vicktor in 4th movie, I can predict she will fall in love with Draco in 6th movie.
post by Ki Ki on 01-16-05 @ 4:08 AM

You missed the most important part of the interview!! Emma said she met Brad Pitt on the set of Troy and they made an agreement to meet each other again in the future. So there you have it. Emma is the reason Brad and Jennifer are splitting up!!LOL!!
post by Crookshanks on 01-16-05 @ 4:48 AM

Lucky Emma or lucky Brad? he's in his forties aint he? *feels ill*
post by Daz on 01-16-05 @ 5:34 AM

I have to say it! I know this magazine, and believe me, it's not reliable! I also said Daniel was quitting after PoA! They haven't been right about anything HP ever!
post by Astra on 01-16-05 @ 5:50 AM

Maybe she will just kiss him on the cheek as a goodbye or something. If it happens : Go Hermione!!! I hope it doesn't happen, though.
Emma is really obsessed with Brad. That's cool.
post by hermy5972 on 01-16-05 @ 6:40 AM

Doreen, that's not strictly true. JKR has final say on everything, they can't change anything that she feels will contradict something in the books or the HP universe. So I think we can all safely assume that even if Hermione does kiss Krum in the film (unlikely) then it's done with her blessing. I just can't see JKR letting them. It might have been in there originally, but she probably asked them to cut it.
post by Loopy on 01-16-05 @ 8:43 AM

that is soooooooo NOT cool!!!!!!!!!
hermione's first kiss (on the cheek or the mouth) should be with Ron!!!!!!!!!!!!

sry ppls........hg/rw shipper........
post by anglophile on 01-16-05 @ 9:06 AM

Actually, Loopy, JKR has final say on nothing. She can tell them "I'd like it if you would do this," but they don't have to. The first two directs have been nice and have done that, but perhaps Newell isn't listening?
post by Pam on 01-16-05 @ 9:41 AM

yeah i was just reading the whole thing and it seems off. the whole kissing thing, first of all, seems really strange. it's so far away from the book and it doesn't really make sense. maybe it could be a kiss on the cheek i dont know. and then rupert grints part was kind of strange. its like they took lines from other interviews and put them all together in one. the whole thing about him saying i dont have anything against emma was really unlike him. he wouldn't have said that.
post by kipsy on 01-16-05 @ 9:46 AM

Well, I think it's perfect. Imagine the face of Ron when he looks that kiss... Oh, how cute a jealous Ron!!!!

I think that kiss will be in the cheek, because, of course, her first kiss will be ONLY with Ron!!!!!!

Yeah, I'm a huge R/Hr shipper!!!!!
post by Leonysse Weasley on 01-16-05 @ 10:00 AM

I notice you were all perfectly okay with all the R/H hints that were not-so-subtly strewed throughout the PoA movie even though they were never mentioned in the books. What is so different about this? If they want to make more romance-oriented films, then increasing the Hermione-Krum relationship in GoF a step is hardly different than increasing the Hermione-Ron relationship in PoA. Also, you all realize that who Hermione ends up with will not determine whether life on Earth continues, right?
post by Jen on 01-16-05 @ 10:13 AM

Do you really think that Hermione would kiss Krum? I mean yes, there are times when Hermione and Krum are together and not seen by Ron and Harry... but in the book, Hermione doesn't seem interested in Krum in that way. I know she tells Ron that somebody already noticed her and that she was glad someone liked her for her, but didn't she also say that she liked him as a friend? I might be crazy, but on the Hogwarts Express on the way back to London... Didn't she tell Ron that she wasn't interested in Krum like that? That part right there would contradict the whole kiss...
post by fawkette on 01-16-05 @ 10:23 AM

if hermione is suppose to get her first kiss in later books...........then jk would not let them.....so if she does.....then it must not be important....so chill out.....and its probaly one on the cheek
post by anna on 01-16-05 @ 10:35 AM

people must protest....we can't let them change the main actors for any of the other movies.....too old or not.....make up artist can to do wonders to make actors look old, young, ugly, pretty etc....so age shouldn't be a problem...besides JK has always discribe certain things like Ron being taller than Harry (already at the age of 15) etc...so even the books are showing that the characters are growing up...hey that's just how it is in real life and that is how the books are too...keeping it as real as possible when it comes to the characters....they are everyday ordinary kids except with magic. I've known some 15 and 16 yr olds that look older but they aren't right...so what's the big deal?! Protest people, Protest lol.
post by hg on 01-16-05 @ 11:41 AM

I am Dutch; the article is translated correctly for those who worry about that.

Personally I don't really think JKR will make a fuss about Hermione's first kiss in the books. Harry is her main character and unless he runs into Hermione kissing someone (or gets kissed by her) then he won't know and we, as readers, won't know. So the movie makers will have a lot of freedom on this.
post by ChaosStorm on 01-16-05 @ 11:45 AM

man, she kisses a guy and i never will. but.....
post by Harry Hotter fan! on 01-16-05 @ 11:49 AM

theres always the possibility that they're going to cut it from the movie. If you think about it, the movie is 2.5hours long, it costs about 300mill to make, there are going to be soooooooooooo many scenes in teh movie that will be cut, they cant fit it in, the movie should b3 3 hours, with an intermission.
post by J Unit on 01-16-05 @ 11:51 AM

Emma does seem a little arrogant in this article. Secondly she really needs to get over Brad Pitt. If Brad went out with a 14 year old it would be the biggest scandal of the year. Also the sentence "I need to kiss one Viktor Krum" does not even make sense. She should have said i need to kiss victor krum one time. And if they do kiss(which i am doubting) it will probably be on the cheek.
post by Harry Hunter on 01-16-05 @ 11:56 AM

brad's single remember? jennifer and brad split a week ago!
post by Harry Hotter fan! on 01-16-05 @ 12:06 PM

And your point is?.........
post by Harry Hunter on 01-16-05 @ 12:08 PM

When she said "one" that meant a boy named Viktor Krum. It's a sort of British speaking. I don't think Emma sounded bratty at all, but rather excited, which she should be.
post by Andrew on 01-16-05 @ 12:20 PM

I love Emma too. She's so cool, and a very good actress!
post by Andrew on 01-16-05 @ 12:53 PM

weezyqueen: I agree that Hermione's first kiss should be with Ron (yay for Ron + Hermione!), but it isn't that big of a deal. Even if Hermione does end up kissing Krum, it doesn't mean that she'll end up marrying him. Oh and could you please stop with the capital letters, it's hard on the eyes :D
post by Wonky Faint on 01-16-05 @ 1:14 PM

wonky faint: i understand what you said about hermione kissing krum not being a big deal.i mean, ofcourse its not like they're going to get married!guess i just wanted it to be a special *fluffy* moment between ron and hermione-you know- sharing they're first kiss with eachother.yea,and 4give me about the CAPS-didnt know it bothered people!sorry!!!!!=)
post by weezyqueen on 01-16-05 @ 1:28 PM

Hey, stop getting sooo freaked out about this ppl!! We all know that Hermione's just doing this all to make Ron jelous :) lol. Awwww so cute. YOUNG LOVE! Trust me, my boyfriend did exactly the same thing to make me jelous. This "kiss" with Krum doesn't even sound very accurate. And if she really did mean to kiss Krum, so what?? It's not like she'll ever see him again... (HAHA!! LMAO!! YOU SUCK KRUM!!) She'll be with Ronnie sooner of later....(Srry If some of you don't agree with me. I'm a Hermione/Ron Shipper) Oh, and btw....I got nothin against Krum, he's a cool guy...BUT NOT WITH HERMIONE!! LOL. Ronnie deserves to be with her....And Harry deserves to be with Loony Lovegood! LMAO! What a wierd couple....hmmm
post by HarryLuver on 01-16-05 @ 1:32 PM

weezyqueen: I totally want Ron and Hermione's first kisses to be with each other too and I think having Hermione kiss Krum is a stupid idea, if not a big deal. Oh and about the caps, you're forgiven ;)
post by Wonky Faint on 01-16-05 @ 1:34 PM

I think this is getting out of hand. I know that I put in my say earlier, but please. Everyone knows that when a book is made into a movie that civil liberites are taken. *sigh* If Hermione kisses Krum, then so be it. We may not like it and it may not agree with the book, but it happens...
post by fawkette on 01-16-05 @ 1:38 PM

I couldn't agree with Jen more. I'm an H/Hr supporter and if there were R/Hr moments put into the thrid movie that were NOT in the book, and you guys weren't complaining, then why not add Hermione/Viktor moments that were not in the book into the fourth movie? I doubt it's going to totally affect the plot, because if it did JKR wouldn't allow it.
post by Kristina on 01-16-05 @ 1:42 PM

this will probably be my last comment.maybe.lol.
i'm glad we agree,wonky faint!!=)(love your name by the way!!!)also, i agree with you harryluver!!!harry and luna r meant 2 be!(although i'm not as sure w/ that couple as i am w/ ron/hermione,ya know.)anyway, yea, maybe thatz my last comment.maybe. :Dhaha:Di love comments!!!
post by weezyqueen on 01-16-05 @ 1:48 PM

Ok here is my theory about that scene:

Krum was going back to the Durmstrang-ship and Hermione wants to kiss him goodbye on the cheek but Krum kissed her on the mouth and Harry and Ron saw it...

Anyways... Tomorrow i will tease my pal Alex who is a huge EW-fan XD
post by Kathy from Sweden on 01-16-05 @ 2:01 PM

Actually Jen and Kristina, I am all for R/Hr and I didn't like the romantic parts between Ron and Hermione in PoA that were so blatantly obvious. In fact, I felt like yelling "THAT wasn't in the book!" But even if the exact moments weren't in the book, there is a general feeling between R/Hr that IS in the books.

I don't mind when they change things for the movie, but in this case, the change seems to have no point whatsoever except to further increase the teen love angle. They seem to be overdoing the raging hormones in GoF.
post by Wonky Faint on 01-16-05 @ 2:02 PM

Man if they do kiss on this flick ill puke at the theater place... by the way u ppl who want hermione's first kiss to be with ron... it already happened in GoF.. or OotP... cant remember... well who cares..
post by D_S on 01-16-05 @ 2:06 PM

When did Hermione kiss Ron? If you mean a kiss on the cheek, that doesn't count.
post by Wonky Faint on 01-16-05 @ 2:08 PM

Well it was a cheek kiss... and for some of the ppl here it does count... for me i dont care i just want to read HBP...
post by D_S on 01-16-05 @ 2:11 PM

Hermione and Ron are cute togehter... But Hermione might really really end up ith Krum, Ron with Luna? (You know, since she's kinda in love with him)... Whatever, I really don't care who the couples end up to be, but this stupid "hormones are racing" thing is bugging me. No kiss occured in the book except when Hermione kissed Harry goodbye, so it better just be like a goodbye kiss. Why do they HAVE to do this kinda of stuff to the movies?
post by Lucy on 01-16-05 @ 2:26 PM

DUH!!!when did cheek kisses ever count,D_S???haha.cheek kisses do not count.they are given to very close friends.if they did count then that would mean hermione loves both harry and ron.in 4 she kisses harry and in 5 she kisses ron.both on the cheek.it's a friend thing.cheek kisses do not count for a 'more-than-friend' gesture.thank you wonky faint for bringing that up.CRAP-i lied-then THIS one can be my last comment.sorry.i am so stupid.lol.dunce<=o
post by weezyqueen on 01-16-05 @ 2:32 PM

OMG ..the book please JUST the book stay concentrate on ti and it could be perfect ..

but someone said " a kiss on the cheek " , yeah it could be possible and that could be ok , please emma could u give us details about the " kiss " ??
post by bou on 01-16-05 @ 2:33 PM

Cheek kisses can be given as greetings, goodbyes, and even to family members, therefore they DO NOT count. How old are you D_S?
post by Wonky Faint on 01-16-05 @ 2:43 PM

Personally, I agree with Jen and ChaosStorm. If it happens, it happens. I like R/Hr, but we also don't know a lot about their interactions with people other than Harry or Gryffs. The story is told through Harry's eyes, so there is a lot about the other characters that we don't. Lexicon shows that alone. Seamus is practically a mystery and he's a dormmate of Harry's.

Just breathe. You usually don't marry the first person you kiss. And if it's on the cheek, well I kissed a lot of boys on the cheek. It's just a gesture. If it's on lips, it might be during Yule Ball. We didn't see Hermione a lot then. Who knows. Either way, relax. Chill out.

Movies always go off course from movies. It happens. POA was very off course (a fact I didn't care much for) so maybe Newell is following that logic. *shrugs* Who knows. We'll all go see it, to compare and either praise or condemn it. There is no telling what will make the final cut. We've still got ten months to go.
post by Thea on 01-16-05 @ 2:46 PM

Ok...

I don't know what to make of this...

1st: the rupert thing about a hug and hand holding.... where in book 4 could that have taken place for the movie people to put it there? I keep trying to think of a time in the books where it didn't say that it happened... that it could have...

2nd: I think It is entirely possible that hermione could kiss krum.... In fact I have believed that hermione was the first of the trio to get a kiss since finishing GOF... because if you will remember at the end of gof... krum comes up and asks to speak to hermione privately to say goodbye... and they go off alone... and ron keeps trying to see what they are up to.

while hermione kissing krum makes me mad... as did the thought of it when I read gof.... I think it could happen.... the movie people might have inferred from that part in gof that that was happening... and if it wasn't what was happening... I will be very happy because I wanted her first kiss to be with ron too!

and it is translated very weird.... it seems like it has a lot of holes....

i dunno
post by Leigh on 01-16-05 @ 2:48 PM

Thanks alot weezyqueen! lol you're pretty cool too! :)
post by Andrew on 01-16-05 @ 3:06 PM

wow, hermione doesn't kiss krum in the book, but she might in the movie... non-readers might get the wrong idea... hopefully if this is true, it will be a kiss on the cheek or viktor will kiss her, but she'll look disgusted and run away... hermione is supposed to be with ron not krum... lol, i guess emma likes brad pitt a lot
post by im_a_muggle on 01-16-05 @ 3:12 PM

Im 16 Wonky Faint.. why do u ask?
and i dont care if theres a kiss or not, i just want to read HBP... I bet theyre going to change the movie alot just like PoA... though PoA is the best movie of the HP films... Cuaron did a great job at it.
post by D_S on 01-16-05 @ 3:24 PM

Oh, I was asking because sometimes, eleven and twelve year olds think that a kiss on the cheek is really meaningful. I was just wondering if you were one of them because I do not think kisses on the cheek are real kisses. I'm 16 too btw.

Anyway I'm gonna stop with the topic of cheek kisses now, cause I have to go and watch the Indy-Patriots game :) GO INDIANAPOLIS! (I know that's off-topic, but it's for good luck)
post by Wonky Faint on 01-16-05 @ 4:02 PM

Cuaron was really good... I just hope that Newall is just as good/better. It would be very disappointing to make the movies go a step backwards. Each movie has gotten better, so I hope they keep that trend. I can't wait to read HBP either! It'll be so exciting to see what happens next in the series.... YAY!! lol The books will always be more exciting/better than the movies, simply because they're written by Jo. Oh, and they come out first. lol :-)
post by Andrew on 01-16-05 @ 4:03 PM

Hermione and Ron aside, I think that Harry should be with Ginny. Aside from Hermione, she's the only girl we know well. I like Luna well enough but I know what it's like to be in Ginny's shoes (as I'm sure a lot of us do.) and I don't think Ron will approve of anybody but Harry being with Ginny.
post by Dina on 01-16-05 @ 4:44 PM

Cauron wasnt good. He made the movie unbelievably dumb and cheesy.

I think that the kiss was most probably a kiss on the cheek and its most probably nothing really that important. She cant kiss his on the lips. She doesnt even like him.. making her kiss him on the lips is suicide. Fans would murder them... but Its probably possible if it was on the cheek. Even if it didnt happen in the books. THis is the movie. They change things all the time... but nothing so drastic.

I dont know why people think that Harry should be with Luna. She just appeared in the books! So what if she could make Harry better in Ootp? It was only one time. Really. Luna and Harry? THey are very different.. even the word opposite doesnt show how far thier personalities really are from each other.
post by Demented on 01-16-05 @ 4:58 PM

I don;t think that Hermione would be able to kiss to someone that is so ugly like him!!!Even on the cheeks, but it will happens,unfortunately
post by Luna on 01-16-05 @ 5:15 PM

Actually, the movies have some differences with the books... I think it's more than possible. Plus, Emma wouldn't lie in an interview, I think...
post by Kathleen on 01-16-05 @ 5:27 PM

For God's sake, people... my best friend kissed our guy friend at a dance and it didn't really mean anything... a kiss is very ambiguous... it could be friendly, romantic, on the cheek, on the lips, good-night.... she didn't specify. the translation was rather rough, who knows. i suppose we'll see when the movie releases.
post by Hermy on 01-16-05 @ 5:53 PM

O no poor Ron will be so sad:( but dont they (ron+herms) hold hands or something
post by Ella on 01-16-05 @ 6:27 PM

poor ron indeed...

maybe they will......maybe they won't

i don't think that emma would give away such a 'juicy' hint for us hp fans........

I WILL NOT ACCEPT IT!!!!!!!!!
post by anglophile on 01-16-05 @ 7:39 PM

You dont have to accept it. Not yet anyway.

It might not happen.
post by Demented on 01-16-05 @ 7:55 PM

I hope Emma doesn't kiss anyone. For goodness sakes she's only 14, and goodness knows we all dislike Krum (at least most of us). I hope Emma will choose to ask to cut out this part, and not kiss Viktor, since he's such an annoying character.
post by Andrew on 01-16-05 @ 7:56 PM

Sorry Andrew, but I think Emma has, like, zero power over the situation.
post by Wonky Faint on 01-16-05 @ 8:57 PM

i think emmas a little too young to be kissing on screen (on the lips) and if she does, where are they going to put it in? it doesn't exactly seem to fit with the story. i think a peck on the cheek to say goodbye seems a lot more reasonable. and i dont think the r/hr shipper need to worry...according to rupert grint there are a lot of r/hr moments.
post by kipsy (again) on 01-16-05 @ 9:40 PM

First of all, something must be said about the comments being posted here. I know that there are a lot of them, and you really don't want to read all of them, but it really does get quite irritating to read the same thing stated over and over again. And please -- PLEASE -- watch your spelling. I know this will go over-looked, but there are very few people here that give a flip about the difference between "their" and "there," but I really can't even understand some of these posts.

Now, on to business.

It's not so much the fact that Hermione doesn't like Krum in that way, as she has so clearly stated in the books, but just that they feel the need to take it upon themselves to waste our time and energy with something that wasn't there to begin with. If she were to kiss him, it would undoubtedly become a huge ordeal, and would last quite a while. Hermione is a main character, and if we see her kiss anyone, it will lead to things. Things that take up time. Granted, these things may contain a jealous Ron (and everyone loves a jealous Ron), but it would be a tainted jealous Ron that was not in the books. If a jealous Ron is what they are trying to get at, there are many other alternatives. For example: Ron defacing the Potion's table while continually asking Hermione whether or not she is going to Bulgaria; Ron pulling the arms off of a Krum action figure; Ron accusing Hermione of "fraternizing with the enemy." Things that are in the books. It really isn't complicated.

I know, if the kiss were to happen, they will find a way for it not to change the course of the books entirely. But really -- REALLY -- what's the point? To an audience that hasn't read the books, Hermione is an intelligent, fierce, irritated goddess of a 14 year old who is very concerned with her hair. If she were to kiss someone, it would mean that she likes them. We all know, of course, that she doesn't like Krum (who ISN'T a bad guy, people), but we have read the books. We know the story. Isn't the whole point of turning books into movies sharing a story with people that don't want to read? That isn't what they've done.

At any rate, I'm simply going to refuse to accept this interview as accurate. Not because of the spelling errors (it is a Dutch magazine, after all), not because Emma seems "arrogant," not because I wouldn't expect the film-makers to do something like this, and definitely not because of anything having to do with Brad Pitt. Just because it would make me far too distraught, and I really don't need that kind of stress right now. And because I'm going to naively pretend that Jo has complete control over absolutely everything that goes into the movies based on her wonderful books.

And finally, since everyone else has been randomly stating their ship, I am an AVID R/Hr supporter, and if there are any H/Hr shippers out there that care, I really am interested to know how in the world you see those two ever getting together. Please e-mail me. I won't bite.

Yay for my token long posts!
post by Jaymee Gudgeon on 01-16-05 @ 10:25 PM

Should I email you? I am a VERY strong H/Hr believer.... lol. And I know Viktor isn't bad, but he is just SO annoying, since it's obvious Harry and Hermione are getting together!
post by Andrew on 01-16-05 @ 10:56 PM

Yes, Andrew, please! I really do want to know what goes on inside the heads of you lot. But this is not the place, so just e-mail me. I'd really appreciate it.
post by Jaymee Gudgeon on 01-16-05 @ 10:59 PM

i agree that hermione's first kiss should be with ron...and if krum and hermione do kiss it will probably be a kiss on the cheek...i hope!
post by Sibyl on 01-16-05 @ 11:38 PM

i hope this movie doent turn out like POA
n i'd really love to see ron's face when hermione kisses krum
lol...
post by ron on 01-17-05 @ 12:41 AM

To the R/Hr shippers:
1. Why shouldn't Hermione kiss any other boy than Ron? Ron is NOT her boyfriend. He has no hold over her.
2. Ron may be jealous when Hermione went out with Krum, but is that a sign that Hermione also has feelings for him?
3. If R/Hr are getting together, why does Hermione continue to write to Krum in book 5?
4. If R/Hr are getting together, why is this link or say, foreshadowing not continued in book 5?

I'm not a H/K shipper but there seems to be some inconsistencies in your arguments.
post by bookworm on 01-17-05 @ 1:46 AM

inconsistencies?

is this coming from an H/Hr shipper?

well if that isn't.... hahahahaha....

I mean....

all the r/hr shippers know what I am talking about here....

inconsistencies!?!?!

hahahahahahaha

that word coming from an H/Hr shipper just cracks me up!

in answer to your questions...

1. No one her is saying Hermione IS going to kiss Ron first and blah blah blah.... they are basically stating that it should be that way.... or that they HOPE it will turn out that way.

2. Ron was jealous when Hermione went out with Krum. But if you read... oh... NOT so closely even... you will see hermione's blatant anger when ron is around fluer...... this isn't saying that Hermione has feelings for ron.... but it sure seems like a bit of jealousy.... and if we are using jealousy to determine ron's feelings for hermione.... then logically... it would/could work the other way around.

3. ever heard the term PEN PALS... Yeah I think hermione uses that term when Ron asks her why she is writing to krum in book 5! I suppose that you would just stop talking to all members of the opposite sex altogether if you liked someone.... you would only talk to them... in fear that god forbid someone think you were dating or interested in someone else!

4. Have you read book 5? It is obvious that Ron and Hermione have become more comfortable around eachother.... but you can tell ron is still jealous of victor.... in above mentioned letter writing scene... which must mean... he still has feelings for hermione... and her is starting to recognize her more for the girl that she is... he gave her perfume on christmas! And hermione gave him a kiss on the cheek, which he reacted strangley to.(Yes Harry got a kiss too... but come on... we can see in his head... and all he thought about it was that it was something hermione had never done... not ... his heart skipped a beat and he knew he was destined to be with the bushy haired witch forever! wouldn't we know if he had felt anything about it?)There is definitely foreshadowing coming from Ron's side of the court still.

there ya go.. i just find it funny that you would bring up the subject of "inconsistencies" ... without out really researching what you are talking about.

Every ship is inconsistent for God's sake.... if they weren't then Hermione would be with Harry cheating with Ron snogging draco in broom closets and having lovely romantic rendezvous' with Snape!

So all ships have holes.... some just go down like the Titanic!
post by Leigh on 01-17-05 @ 3:02 AM

Honestly, who gives a ship (can I say that Matthew) about what incorrect interpretations they put into the movies.
We've seen the first three and know how loosely they are based on the books, so why should the remainder be any different.

The important stuff is what Jo writes in the books and what's coming up in book 6.
post by *Ginny* on 01-17-05 @ 4:48 AM

Does it really matter, NO! Other stuff like changing characters behaviour and role fundamentally is far worse. A kiss could have very well taken place although I personally doubt it, I think in the end of GoF Krum took Hermione aside and asked her how she felt about him and if it was Harry she likes (I mean he was very jealous of Harry).

Hermione and Ron I don't think it will happen. A relation between Harry and Hermione is growing stronger with each book since PoA, it's bound to happen. The catalyst is already introduced, her being wounded in the MoM battle because Harry didn't listen to her. I see enough signs from Ron towards hermione but all the signs Hermione is giving of are that she likes Harry and it fits perfectly in the type of guy she seems to like.
post by Blablabla on 01-17-05 @ 7:51 AM

Re: bookworm.
I see zero "inconsistencies"

1. I agree, Hermione can kiss whomever she wants. That said, I just don't think Hermione is the type to go kissing someone that she barely knows (ahem Krum!). Hermione is, after all, a bit of a -for lack of a better word- prude.

2. No, it's not a sign that Hermione likes Ron. But I, personally, think that Hermione only likes Krum as a friend and is too nice to ditch him. And I'd also like to echo Leigh's comment about Hermione's jealousy towards Ron's purely physical crush on Fleur.

3. She continues to write to Krum because they are FRIENDS. And again, Hermione is generally nice and considerate about people's feelings (with the obvious exception of Malfoy and Pansy :D)

4. You need to re-read OotP. There is plenty in there that hints at Ron and Hermione's growing feelings for each other.

Even with my feelings on the matter of who's going to shack up with whom, I'm starting to wish that Jo would make every one of them into a hermit. Not a lot of fun but it would spare us the heated, um, disagreements. At least the Neville-Luna ship has sailed. Thank god. What were those people thinking?
post by Wonky Faint on 01-17-05 @ 8:36 AM

Wonky Faint, I've stayed quiet pretty much on the R/Hr ship I support. But. I have to say I like Luna/Neville. *shrugs* Why? Because she's honest, maybe a little strange but honest. She's an outsider, she sees Neville for what he is, and not the nuisance Harry tends to think of Neville as. That's important to someone who's nice but shy. And Neville could keep her a bit more grounded, when the time comes.
post by Thea on 01-17-05 @ 8:58 AM

Well I respect your opinion, Thea but I'm still quite glad that Jo squashed that couple on her website. I like Luna and Neville's characters, just not them together. Oh and yes Harry can think of Neville as a nuisance sometimes (let's face it, he occasionally is) but when it comes right down to it, Harry thinks Neville is a loyal friend and is glad to have him on his side.
post by Wonky Faint on 01-17-05 @ 10:19 AM

yeah, Thea, Jo killed that ship on her site last year. I thought it was nice too, though.
post by Andrew on 01-17-05 @ 10:42 AM

i think the funniest thing is people arguing on pages like this hehehe:)
post by big_bad_slytherin on 01-17-05 @ 10:54 AM

I'm from Belgium were Joepie is published and I'm giving you the good advice to not take this seriously. About a year ago they had an interview with Daniel in it and it said that he and Emma Watson were supposed to kiss in the PoA. And as all of you know that wasn't in here so... This one will be fake as well. And oh.. I read this interview something about 3 or 4 months ago and I really don't think that Emma was allowed to say all this already than!!!
post by Marie on 01-17-05 @ 11:26 AM

All right, since no one e-mailed me, I guess this is the official ship vs ship discussion site.

Ahem. Inconsistencies. Right.

First, let's just put this one to rest. The kiss in GoF doesn't count as proof that Harry likes Hermione. I would hope that even H/Hr shippers know this, but it may need to be explained. We can see inside of Harry's head, he would have said something about a tingly sensation he got when she did it if he liked her. This has been said before, but who knows? It may have been avoided. Harry does not like Hermione. End of story.

I would hope that everyone can agree that Ron likes Hermione. He definitely reacted differently to his Hermione kiss than Harry. Even Harry noticed that he was acting weird afterwards, and let's face it -- Harry can be downright nonperceptive most of the time. And yes, Ron demonstrates his emotions through jealousy. He rips the arms off of his favorite Quidditch player because of Hermione. He never leaves her alone about Krum, even after a year. I really don't even feel the need to lay out every single moment in all of the books that shows, so incredibly obviously, that Ron likes Hermione. Just read them. Forwards. You'll see it, people.

So I assume that the only question here is: Who does Hermione like? At the moment, she is clearly more concerned with her school life and Voldemort's return to worry about having a boyfriend. She deeply cares for both Harry and Ron, but most of the time what we see as evidence for a ship's existence is just Hermione being a good friend. However.

"Next time there's a ball, ask me before someone else does and not as a last resort!"

I know the arguments. She didn't mean it like that, she was just proving that she knew Ron likes her...whatever. Read it as you will. Keeping in mind Hermione's personality or completely disregarding it.

Anyway -- how did we stray so far from the topic? Hermione kissing Krum. Clearly, it is an important point. What are we arguing about anyway? Who Hermione likes, right? Isn't this same point reflected in who she kisses? It's a big deal, people. If you don't think it is, then God bless you, for you have the immortal will power to not care a bit how the movies interpret the books.

See, they shouldn't make moves based on their opinions and interpretations of the books. They should make movies that ARE the books, and let other people have their own opinions about other things than whether or not Dan is good-looking.

As for the ship debates -- seriously, guys. If there are any H/Hr-ers out there that feel like sharing hard evidence with me, I would really like to know where you're getting this stuff. But, at the moment, I've received nothing, so I'm assuming that no one can find anything. Until then.
post by Jaymee Gudgeon on 01-17-05 @ 11:55 AM

Jaymee, I doubt that you'll get any e-mails from the H/Hr shippers. They have no evidence to work on their behalf.
post by Wonky Faint on 01-17-05 @ 12:42 PM

jaymee........
HOW DO YOU KNOW WHAT HERMIONE WAS THINKING?????

YOU DON'T!!!!!!!!!!!!& #33;!!!!!

like what wonky faint said i seriously doubt that you'll get any e-mails........
post by anglophile on 01-17-05 @ 1:10 PM

WOAH!! so much fuse or something so not worth it...which is not even going to happen since its probaly fake...woah u people have no life if u are able to sit here hours at a time and fight like this
post by anna on 01-17-05 @ 1:13 PM

I´m sorry, but this is really scary...Remember the old "Hot Chocolate" song: "It started with a kiss", like you said anna, this whole thing is probably fake...And IF the producers DO add a kiss (on the cheek perhaps) between Hermione and Krum,,SO WHAT, it´s not the end of the world you know..Like Astra said in an earlier comment, this magazine is as reliable as toilet paper, ok she didn´t use that sentence
post by Sonja on 01-17-05 @ 2:24 PM

stand up sit down fight fight fight!!!
post by yea on 01-17-05 @ 3:08 PM

p.s. Patience is a Virtue!
post by Shawti on 01-17-05 @ 3:27 PM

Let them fight. It's funny!
post by Dobby on 01-17-05 @ 3:49 PM

Yeah girlfight girlfight...or even better mudfight mudfight lol...
post by Sonja on 01-17-05 @ 4:30 PM

I don't know why I'm defending myself to people so ignorant, but here it is.

We know that we can't do anything about it. We know that if it happens, it happens, and the world will go on either way. We know that these are just fictional characters in a fictional story. But this is what most of us live for -- watching the series come to life on the big screen. We just want it to be perfect. We want to share our opinions about anything and everything. Sure, we will get into heated arguments, flames will be sent, casualties will surface, but in the end, we all love Harry Potter, and if you don't like it then you can just leave.
post by Jaymee Gudgeon on 01-17-05 @ 5:07 PM

I hear you loud and clear, Jaymee. Oh and if you want to see what a H/Hr shipper thinks then go on the 'On Demand' PoA Video news post and read Kristy's comment near the bottom. I gave up and wrote one sentence to her in disagreement.
post by Wonky Faint on 01-17-05 @ 5:46 PM

Thanks, Wonky Faint. I really enjoyed reading that...deep...logic, as well as your simple comment to it.

Still haven't gotten any e-mails...but I guess that should have been expected.
post by Jaymee Gudgeon on 01-17-05 @ 6:37 PM

I understand it's been shot down. I'm just saying that I still enjoy it. Write it. Whatever. She shot Draco/Hermione down too, but people still write and want it to happen. *shrugs* And are you sure he counts Neville as a friend? Really? Is that way he doesn't invite him along with the Trio? Thought he would be useless at the DoM, along with Ginny and Luna? I don't think he considers anyone but Hermione and Ron as friends. The rest to him are merely schoolmates. Just an opinion of course.
post by Thea on 01-17-05 @ 8:10 PM

Sorry for the wrong spelling. I was in a hurry.
1. Somebody here said that Hermione shouldn't kiss anybody else but Ron.
2. I agree with Jaymee. Ron's jealousy is obvious, not so Hermione.
3. Of course, there are penpals. I've never met one however who write "novels" to each other.
4. There is foreshadowing of R/Hr in GoF but this was not carried through to book 5. I was quite disappointed in that actually as Hermione doesn't seem to return Ron's feelings but seems to just see him as the jealous type.

I'm not really a H/Hr shipper for two reasons:
1. Hermione shows deep concern and loyalty for Harry. There is a bond there and I have to agree with Jaymee. There is however no obvious sign that Harry has more than brotherly feelings towards Hermione so I don't want to get on that ship in case it sinks.
2. Only Jo can tell us who "shacks" up with whom so i prefer to wait until July to know for sure and avoid these bad feelings with my fellow HP fans.
post by bookworm on 01-17-05 @ 8:21 PM

I hate it when they change things like that~ Hermione's supposed to KISS HARRY, like in the BOOK!!!! Not Krum, and definitely NOT RON!!! Nono, sorry R/Hr shippers here, Ron does seem to like Hermione but Hermione doesn't show any in return.
post by sandar on 01-17-05 @ 8:36 PM

dun mean to offend any R/Hr shippers here, but I feel that R/Hr are more like brother/sister. Just look at the way Ron treats Ginny!i think the R/Hr ship is the one ship that lacks clues/evidence. it's always the "it's obvious" statement when it's not at all obvious who Hermione likes. Altho I ship H/Hr, I can see why ppl ship H/G (coz there are evidence and clues for that ships too), but so far I have not seen any good essay supporting R/Hr~ Oh, and if u want clues of H/Hr, go read all the essays. Here's a good place to start:

http://talk.portkey.org/index.php?showforum=43
post by sandar on 01-17-05 @ 8:52 PM

well in my opinion hermione is not showing blatant feelings toward any of the boys.... we see through Harry's eyes in the book so we see her concern and kindness toward him... but there is no doubt in my mind that hermione would show the same concern and kindness to ron if he were in harry's shoes. And contrary to popular belief we don't see ron and hermione bickering any time they are together... I believe that she may have feelings toward someone.... but she is really good at hiding it... and just because she shows kindness and care and concern toward person doesn't merit the thought that she is madly in love with them!

I won't sit here and go into the possibilites of ways hermione could show her feelings here... because arguing with you lot is like arguing with a donkey... they aren't going to listen or change their ways... they are just going to sit their content in their ignorance!

and if that was to harsh for you... i don't care... that's how it is in my eyes!
post by Leigh on 01-17-05 @ 8:58 PM

Leigh, you are so right. I don't know why I waste my time. Like arguing with a brick wall, it is. We all know we're right, even if we're wrong, and the only thing that will ever give us any doubt is what JKR has to say. *sigh* I'm so tired now.
post by Jaymee Gudgeon on 01-17-05 @ 9:43 PM

jaymee... check your email... I sent ya one!
post by Leigh on 01-17-05 @ 10:08 PM

I am a R/Hm person. It fits in so perfectly with the growing up theme. They fought as little children, but got older and see each other in a different light.
post by Shane on 01-17-05 @ 10:48 PM

I'm not going to make any further comments on the matter except to say once again that Hermione's kiss on the cheek to Harry means NOTHING. It's a goodbye, "I feel bad that you have to go with the Dursley's" kiss. A kiss on the cheek is not a real kiss. When Hermione kisses Harry on the cheek, there is obviously NO romantic undertone.

Anyway I'm not going to make any more shipping comments on here because it's boring. Everyone has an opinion and everyone will always have an opinion.
post by Wonky Faint on 01-18-05 @ 2:47 PM

It's true, Wonky Faint. There is no point. It's insane that a topic concerning Hermione kissing Krum can lead to such graphic ship arguments. And this isn't some kind of thing that anyone can switch sides on after reading what we mere mortals have to say. JKR has to supply us with definite proof -- and even then, some ships will sail on in their minds.

Republicans vs Democrats
Christians vs Jews
R/Hr-ers vs H/Hr-ers

If you feel strongly about certain topics, you will just never change your mind.
post by Jaymee Gudgeon on 01-18-05 @ 3:58 PM

yes both jaymee and wonky faint are right.....
we must unite as HP fans......
post by anglophile on 01-18-05 @ 4:25 PM

Shane-they still fight like little children sometimes!
post by Dobby on 01-18-05 @ 6:42 PM

A Hermione tem q ficar com o Harry!!!!!!!
vcs sabem q aqui no brasil Harry Potter é super famoso e faz o maior susseso pois o filme é d++++ e eu acho q a Hermione e o Harry fazem um casal tão lindinho vcs ñ acham? e de qualquer forma eles tem q ficar juntos mais q coisa!!!!!!!!!!
bom eu sei q vcs ñ entendem nada do q eu escrevi mais valeu né, pena q ninguem vai entender patavina do q eu disse!!!!!!!! bbbbbjjjjjjjjooooooosssss da "FRAN DO BRASIL"
post by francine a super brasileira!! on 01-19-05 @ 9:48 PM

Jessi-
Yah, I believe you're right. why would Emma be interviewed by a Dutch magazine, wherin she lives in UK. How can that be possible? If Jamie Waylett wasn't able to say who were the Weird Sisters, why did Emma tell that she'll kiss Vicky?
Wonky Faint-
Yes, I believe so because a simple kiss in the cheek just means a sign of greeting or goodbye. If ever one of the characters (especially Hermione in this case)will kiss the other on the lips, I must comment that the chances of Hermione lovin that charcter is very big indeed
post by badjao24 on 01-20-05 @ 5:58 AM

No! Emma is only 15!


SHE IS YOUNG GIRL! ㅠㅠ
post by KOREAN on 01-23-05 @ 1:37 AM

Viktor is perhapse a good boy,but I can not understand how they can change the books "Old" history!!!!:(
post by Swedish Potter-Love on 01-23-05 @ 9:41 AM

It`s there moore people from Sweden on this site?:)
post by Swedish Potter-Love on 01-23-05 @ 9:47 AM

Can anybody from Sweden answer my question?Please!!!!!:D
post by Swedish Potter-Love on 01-27-05 @ 8:36 AM

Or not.....:(
post by Swedish Potter-Love on 01-29-05 @ 10:36 AM

I could care less if there's kissing or not.
Just looking forward to the film and book, so I can enjoy both.
post by Dylan on 01-30-05 @ 8:30 AM

I think that hermione should kiss HARRY!!!!!!!!!!!!! !
NOt KRUM AND neather ron harry/hermione are the perfect cople that's my opinion
post by ariadna on 01-30-05 @ 2:44 PM

I really think they should go by the book.And i think that interview is a fake!!!!!!! After all, JK Rowling first became famous by her books, not the movies. No books, no movies. Hermione should definitely have her first kiss with Ron. It doesn't seem like Hermione and Krum really go together. He doesn't even say her name right. Which really isn't his fault but she will probably get aggravated with him after a while.
post by Anna on 01-31-05 @ 11:08 AM

I've read about 100000000 interviews, and that definatley isnt emma. she just doesnt talk like that.
stupid git whoever wrote it.
post by Trill* on 01-31-05 @ 5:58 PM

Movies cannot quite express things that movies can. The directors of the previous films have added in other cute little moments of Ron/Hermione so that when the Yule Ball conflict appears it doesn't appear out of the blue. A kiss would be the perfect way to get little Ronnie to express some of his jealousy that is expressed in the book that a movie cannot capture.

R/H FOREVER!!!!!!!!!! YEAH !0
post by Krissy on 01-31-05 @ 6:09 PM

NOOOOOO!!!

Will be better if Hemione's first kiss will be with Ron!!!
Just show Ron's jealousy only by Hermione & Krum's closeness but not intimacy such as kissing. For the next movie (HP5) the story will not be interesting anymore.

Frankly, In the last series, I'm hoping Ron will be Hermione's soulmate. :)

about Harry... Maybe it's nice if Hedwig is a Animagus, and change into a beautiful woman to be Harry's soulmate...

Just a suggestion... :)
post by Uwie on 02-03-05 @ 10:24 PM

I think that Hedwig turning into a beautiful women is a little far fetched. No offence though.I think that hedwig will stay harry's owl and not turn into his soulmate. It is hard to say who his soulmate will be.Only JKR can know and all we can do is guess how it will be.

No offence about the Hedwig thing.
post by You Know on 02-04-05 @ 9:42 PM

i don't know. but how do u people know that they did not kiss in the book? it is always from harry's point of view and hermione probably does not tell them everything about her and victor. remember at the end when victor asks to talk to hermione alone? maybe they kissed then. u really can't know yet whether they did or not.
post by julia on 02-04-05 @ 10:58 PM

(julia)u r right its always at harrys view so they cud ave kissed no 1 no's u dont no wat da others r doin u only no wat harrys doin but i wud profer if she kissed ron b coz der is no point of kissin harry coz he gets everythin he wants and we all no dat ron and herm really like each other so i dont thin she shud kiss krum but if it happens it happens its up to da film makers anyway.
post by sam on 02-08-05 @ 8:44 AM

Emma is way young! And the guy iz 18 or 17! Besides I'm
cheerin for Hermione and Harry, I think they make a cute couple.
post by Alyssa Cruz on 02-08-05 @ 3:20 PM

Hermione doesn't like Krum enough to kiss him in the book. They're twisting the whole thing. And personnally, emma is too vain. I mean Brad Pitt? Who is she kidding?
post by Bellatrix Lestrange on 02-10-05 @ 10:54 AM

I think that Emma just say something,but not in earnest,perhap`s................
post by Moody Maja on 02-16-05 @ 11:01 AM

This what I think:

Emma answered Brad Pitt because she wanted have attention.......
post by Me on 02-17-05 @ 8:38 AM

well i think that hermione should kiss harry because it's in the fourth book. they are totally straying from the book.
post by becky on 02-21-05 @ 9:51 AM

Emma and Krum are beautiful united, kiss,

Lia
post by lia on 02-26-05 @ 8:11 PM

i THINK THat the "kiss" onscreen IS A WAY RON WILL FIND OUT HE(RON)LIKES hERMIONE SO i THINK THAT ADDING THIS TO GOF IS GOOD CAUSE WE'D HAF TO WAIT TILL THE SIX BOOK TO SEE SOME JEALOUSY FROM HIM i DON'T CARE THAT IT'S NOT IN THE BOOK THE MAIN PLOT IS THE SAME SO WHY NOT spice it SO LONG AS J.K. HAS NO OBJECTIONS And a shout out to all the guys struggling to get to 7/16/05!!!!!!!!!!
member only five more months
though i am still pulling for the hermione-ron-harry love triangle!!!!!!!!!
post by LoisLane88 on 02-26-05 @ 8:36 PM

I think the only reason Harry and Hermione don't get to close to each other is because Harry will die! Harsh, I know but there is a big twist in one of the two upcoming books that will explain everything. I think it has something to do with Dumbledore and Voldemort? Don't worry not even I know what it is, or do I??????
Hope I keep you guessing till my next posting.
post by KryptonEgg on 02-26-05 @ 8:44 PM

hermione kisses x charecter i got strong feelings about that and two times on some one else
mitchell
post by mitchell on 03-02-05 @ 12:29 PM

i think u people should seriously calm down...

lol... -_-;;;;;;;;;;;

"i just can't wait for GoF..."
post by lol on 03-16-05 @ 7:47 PM

HERMIONE AND KRUM WILL NEVER KISS, HERMIONE WILLL KISS HARRY!!!!
post by Danny Desimone on 03-18-05 @ 9:26 PM

Hermione and Krum,Ron and Hermione I think thats a Big.....Eow!!!They cant make cute couple u know.HARRY and HERMIONE is the perfect couple.Just like in real life,Dan and Emma.And Krum,Weasley sorry,both of u will not be the 1st kiss of hermione,it will be H-A-R-R-Y
post by Mildred Lee on 03-28-05 @ 7:52 AM

I think only J.K. was the only one who can change anything an the story.She can write R/Hr (oh!no!) maybe Vicky/Hr (never!) or H/Hr (plz.I beg you J.k).Or she can put the trio in a love triangle.
post by Mildred on 03-28-05 @ 8:03 AM

look guys i have read all of your comments and they have been the highlight of my day.you guys don't realilize how crazy you sound,but don't worry i'm here to join you.(i love harry potter so much!!!)Chill out about the Krum&Hermione thing,we all Know it won't happen as for
H/Hr and R/Hr only time,printing presses,and spare reading will tell.

PS
i haven't had time to change it to something better
post by Natalie on 03-31-05 @ 7:29 PM

I think is a good idear that Hermione kisses Krum. I think this movie will be great.
post by prince on 04-02-05 @ 5:29 AM

Well Kaitlyn I hae to say this, But It is possible that the kiss will HAPPEN. Because in Hp book 5 Hermione said 'Voldemort' for the first time. But in the 2nd movie she had already said. So the kiss is possible.
post by Tonigirl on 04-02-05 @ 3:06 PM

Y'all i'm a huge HG/RW shipper here and I think that JK would never let that happen. Hermione's fist kiss will so happen i the 6th book! I just can't wait for the next book!

HG/RW all the way!
post by summer on 04-03-05 @ 1:29 PM

I think that hermione's first kiss must be with ron...and sooner,please!!!!I wanna say that the site is great and it seems to be the best!!!!I must say tha i'm argentinian,and maybe my english is not very good...i'm sory!
summer's ok...HG/RW all the way!!!!!
post by rupertfan on 04-16-05 @ 4:06 PM

ya'll chill 4 a bit.....whatz all da fuss abt? so what if she kisses krum? so what if she doesnt? its just a freakin movie. dun get me wrong, i luv hp, but theres a limit...dun u think? MOVIES R 4 ENTERTAINMENT, DUN BREATHE ON IT.

---sincerely, starrypunk---
post by starrypunk on 05-07-05 @ 5:00 AM

I really like the idea of hermionie kissing Krum{imagine Ron's face!!!!!!}
post by moony on 05-08-05 @ 8:14 PM

I really like the idea of hermionie kissing Krum{imagine Ron's face!!!!!!}
post by moony on 05-08-05 @ 8:14 PM

I too would enjoy Rons face if Hermione kissed Krum, but i think that everyones insane thinking that hermione and Ron could be a couple or even kiss!!
I think that Hermione and HARRY should kiss and become a couple,
it makes loads more sense for Harry and Hermione to be together.
Don't get me wrong, i think its a good idea that Ron and Hermione kiss, i just think that Harry And Hermione make more sense!
post by Rhys on 05-10-05 @ 2:33 PM

They can't do that! Hermione should kiss ron first and not viktor. It's not in the book.Don't change the movie so much.
post by Alisha on 05-19-05 @ 5:40 AM

Maybe they did it 4 Emma
like "here ya go! ya get to kiss a guy!" like a really good b-day present
no, i don't really think that
Or do I?
post by Gabby on 05-23-05 @ 11:42 PM

I think that HG/RW should be together. it's obivous!!!!
post by MIMI on 05-25-05 @ 7:59 PM

HArry and Ginny a good together.\
post by MIMI on 05-25-05 @ 8:03 PM

THIS IS CRAP!!!!!!!!!!
WHAT ARE THEY SMOKING!!!
IF SHE ACTUALLY DOES I WILL BE SO MAD!!!
EMMA IS HOT, MAN AND THAT WOULD SUCK IF SHE HAD TO KISS HIM!
post by Shogun on 06-08-05 @ 7:32 PM

I always thought Harry and Hermonie looked good. Ron and Hermonie makes sence but she hangs out with Harry more!
I can't believe this!
I would love to see the look on Ron or Harry's face sure but...Why does it have to be Krum?! In the book he sounds nice but why Krum why not Ron or even Harry?!

--Padfoot--
post by Padfoot on 06-11-05 @ 7:30 PM

The whole thing seems wierd. Hermonie kissing Krum that's out o' wack! I agree with Padfoot on this 1. It sucks bigtime!!!! Ron is a really good choice 4 her but so's Harry!

!!!!Remus Lupin!!!!
post by Remus Lupin on 06-11-05 @ 7:36 PM

like many of you have said, hermione might just kiss krum goodbye and her first major kiss MIGHT be w/ ron, but i am still going for harry/hermione cuz harry has had a lot of the same things as his dad james-the look and didn't get prefect. james ended up being head boy and getting together w/ lily, a muggle-born, so harry might be head boy and he might get together w/ hermione, who is also a muggle-born like lily.
post by bw526 on 06-22-05 @ 11:59 AM

Oh!no,
I never read this in any harry`s book, i think she is intrested in kissing him unless there is a scene in the film or book how can she kiss some one who is not worthful of it!
post by k.v.r.murthy on 06-26-05 @ 6:04 AM

I don't think Emma is interested in kissing Krum. But she sure is keen on kissing brad pitt
post by hey on 06-28-05 @ 11:39 AM

i think that u all should see the movie and then write a complaint letter to the directors if u do not agree with whaterever Emma has done in the movie, and ask them to keep it a little bit more like the book please!!!

Personaly, i think that the directors wouldn't put a scene like that in the movie cuz their only 14.
post by nikki on 06-29-05 @ 7:51 PM

i cannot wait for goblet of fire to come out! do u guys no of any good trailer sites where i can whatch?
post by nikki on 06-29-05 @ 7:57 PM

reading ur comments are awsome but i"m going to predict that harry and hermione relize that there ment 4 each other in the 6 book but watever it is i"ll be fine.(not really. GO HARRY AND HERMIONE.) oh and nikki u can see the trailer in gobletoffire.com i saw and it is awsome.
post by hr/hg fan on 07-03-05 @ 10:32 PM

YES!!!...GO HARRY AND HERMIONE!!!! I THINK THAT ONE SIDE OF OURSELVES KNOW THAT HERMIONE LOVES HARRY!!!
post by SUPERFAN on 07-09-05 @ 2:57 AM

YES NIKKI!!!...I CANOT WAIT AT ALL FOR GLOBET OF FIRE! I MEAN....IM DYING TO SEE THE MOVIE !!...I THINK THAT EMMA DOES WANT TO KISS DANIEL ..BUT SHE JUST CANT ACEPTED BECAUSE DANIEL IS LIKE HER BEST FRIEND....AND IT WOLD BE WEIRD IF SHE KISS HIM..YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN!!
post by SUPERFAN on 07-09-05 @ 3:02 AM

IN THE GOF BOOK WHEN THEY ARE AT THE DANCE RON SEEMS SORT OF JEALOUS.WHAT IF SHE DIDNT KISS HIM IN THE BOOK PPL ARE ALWAYS DOING THAT SO WE MIND AS WELL GET USED TO IT .WHO KNOWS IF HERM AND RON MIGHT HOOK UP IN THE 6TH BOOK CAUSE SHE IS VERY UNPREDICTABLE IF ITS A FAKE ITS FAKE WAIT TILL THE MOVIE YOULL FIND OUT
post by NATASHA on 07-14-05 @ 12:41 PM

WHY WOULD HARRY AND HERM HOOK UP JK DOESNT DROP ANY HINTS ABOUT IT DUUUUUUUUUUUUHHHHHHHHHHHH!
post by NATASHA on 07-14-05 @ 12:44 PM

YAY! im so happy that people agree w/ me. go harry/hermione!! btw i have more proof that harry/hermione will be together. if you look under "verified info for the sixth book" on this website, it says that harry and cho will not get back together, so harry can be w/ hermione!!
post by bw526 on 07-20-05 @ 1:50 PM

uhhhh it's Ron Hermione just to clarify with people reading this. J.K. said it, and Book 6 confirms it. Ciao!
post by r/Hr fanatic on 08-08-05 @ 2:46 PM

If any of you read book 6, you wouldnt be surprised of Hermione kissing Krum if my memory's correct of what Ron said...
post by nyechos on 08-15-05 @ 6:45 PM

I don't think Harry And Hermione will get together. It's always been Ron and Hermione, and I think they will go out in the 7th book, and maybe have there first kiss.
post by Heather on 08-17-05 @ 4:35 PM

Very nice blog. It is very helpful. http://www.bignews.com
post by miglena on 08-18-05 @ 7:24 PM

Well no spoiler for 6th book here but sufficient to say kissing Krum wont conflict with JK's books.
post by pie31415926 on 08-19-05 @ 7:37 PM

I DON
post by RAB on 08-22-05 @ 3:15 PM


Post a Comment

Name Password (admin only) Email